Port Authority’s annual service report shows ridership continues to be strong, but the agency made few improvements in its performance in key areas such as cost and on-time performance in relation to its peers.
CEO Katharine Eagan Kelleman said Thursday the agency has plans and processes in place to address those items and expects to show progress in the next few years. The report, which the agency has prepared the past four years, was presented to the board’s Planning & Stakeholder Relations Committee Thursday.
Good news: The authority’s overall ridership increased 2% in 2018 to 64.2 million, completely pushed by a 3.3% increase in bus riders. Ms. Kelleman said that is particularly positive since there was no major increase in service and it bucks the trend of falling ridership in other transit agencies.
Light rail ridership fell 5.5 percent, largely attributed to the freight train derailment that blocked the South Side station and flooding on the Library line last year that delayed service for several months on the Port Authority rail system overall. Incline ridership also dropped 4% and the use of ACCESS paratransit was down 2.9% but there was no clear reason why.
The bad news: Despite Ms. Kelleman setting a goal of improving on-time performance from 66.7% to 73% in her first year at the agency, it actually dropped last year to 65.7%. That was lower than all five of its peers who use the same standard for on time — from one minute early to five minutes late is considered on time — and substantially lower than four who had buses that were on time 80% of the time or better.
In many cases, Ms. Kelleman said, the agency didn’t have personnel in place to address its shortcomings. For example, it had one person handling scheduling for all four divisions, where other agencies have one for each division, and had no one analyzing millions of pieces of data the system collects about who uses the system, when they use it and where they go.
Now, those positions have been added, along with a new director of service planning and scheduling, Phillip St. Pierre, who started about two months ago. He had worked with Ms. Kelleman at the Hillsborough Area Regional Transit Authority in Tampa, Fla., where on-time performance improved by 11 percent over five years.
“It’s a better system now than it was last year,” Ms. Kelleman said. “I would like to see us making more progress, but we’re hearing about the problems and we can deal with them.

“You’ll see incremental improvements. If we don’t get [to the on-time performance goal] this year, then we’ll try something else.”
Chief Development Officer David Huffaker noted that on-time performance has increased almost 2 percentage points so far in 2019, which he said could be the start of long-term improvements.
Staff is analyzing the existing time schedules and routes to see if they are realistic and what changes can be made to make them more reliable, Mr. St. Pierre said. The agency also is looking at other steps to reduce operating costs and keep buses in service rather than going back and forth to garages, including ideas like taking relief drivers to buses when a driver’s shift is over and allowing drivers to eat lunch on the road rather than going back to the garage.
The agency also is looking to make more buses available as replacements when vehicles break down on the road and to get the replacements there faster.
Although he’s only been in Pittsburgh a short time, Mr. St. Pierre said the system is more challenging than the operation in Tampa because many routes pass through Downtown. That means one traffic accident or other problem Downtown has a ripple effect across the system because it delays multiple routes.
Planning Director Amy Silbermann said the agency also is looking for more dedicated bus lanes such as the proposed Bus Rapid Transit system between Downtown and Oakland, which should experience fewer traffic delays.
Other areas where Port Authority lags behind its peers are the amount of time vehicles are collecting revenue while they are on the road, cost per passenger and cost of light rail service, highest out of eight agencies.
Ms. Kelleman said the authority is working with the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation to develop a study and hire a consultant to review the high operating cost of light rail, which at $8.11 is more than $2 per passenger higher than its nearest peer. The authority’s system is unique in that it is based on the old streetcar system and uses a different track gauge than most others, but Ms. Kelleman said that’s not an acceptable reason for high costs.
“Maybe it’s not that the wacky gauge is different that makes our costs higher,” she said. “If we’re going to run it, we have to run it the right way. PennDOT has been a good partner and will help us figure this out.”
Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1470 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.