The Pennsylvania Turnpike won’t bundle the rehabilitation of five tunnels under one contract because it shouldn’t borrow the upfront money it would need for the project.

That’s the conclusion turnpike chief engineer Brad Heigel announced last week in a letter to the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation’s Office of Public-Private Partnerships. Although the project has “definite, tangible merits,” Mr. Heigel said, the agency isn’t in a position to borrow up to $350 million it could take to fund the project and doesn’t want to defer other work in favor of the tunnels.

PennDOT asked the turnpike to consider issuing one contract for fixing the tunnels after receiving an unsolicited proposal last year.

“It is intriguing how a bundled tunnel program could deliver fully rehabilitated tunnels along an accelerated timeline,” Mr. Heigel wrote. “While this proposal appears to meet many technical objectives, the financing side to the transaction has its challenges.”

Advertise with us

The turnpike has plans to upgrade tiles, HVAC, and water and electrical equipment at five sets of tunnels over the next 10 to 15 years: Allegheny (6,050 feet long) in Somerset County; Tuscarora (1.1 mile long) at the Huntingdon-Franklin county line; Lehigh (4,380 feet long) on the Lehigh-Carbon county border; Kittatinny (4,727 feet long) in Franklin County; and Blue Mountain (4,339 feet long) 600 feet from Kittatinny in Franklin County. Lehigh opened in 1957 on the turnpike’s Northeast Extension, but the others were part of original construction in the 1930s and ’40s.

In January, the turnpike advertised the possibility of issuing one contract for the tunnel work and received 13 requests for information. The concept would have involved a contractor fixing all of the tunnels over five or six years and being responsible for maintenance for about 30 years for an upfront payment in the range of $350 million.

But the turnpike already carries a debt load of $11.8 billion and must pay about $600 million of debt service as part of its annual budget of around $950 million. As a result, it shouldn’t borrow more money for the tunnel program, Mr. Heigel said.

“There are definite, tangible merits to a design/build/finance/maintain delivery mechanism for this program,” Mr. Heigel told PennDOT. “Unfortunately, our current and foreseeable financial state does not couple well to a long-term availability payment structure.”

The turnpike will proceed with upgrading the Tuscarora Tunnel this year.

Advertise with us

Mr. Heigel previously said the tunnels are “very sound” structurally. In addition to annual costs of about $1 million per set of tunnels for operations and maintenance, the turnpike conducts inspections every other year.

Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1470 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.