The Pennsylvania Department of Transportation is taking a proactive — and costly — approach to meeting new federal guidelines for guardrail design across the country.
Next year, the state will begin a three-year process to replace the ends of all guardrails on interstate highways with an “end terminal” that is about 4 inches higher than the current rails at a cost of about $45 million.
In addition, the state will add $26 million to $46 million a year over the next 12 to 15 years to upgrade guardrails on non-interstate roads, Transportation Secretary Leslie S. Richards announced last week.
The program is the state’s response to new guardrail guidelines recommended two years ago by the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials as part of its ongoing review of safety standards. The guidelines that went into effect July 1 must be followed by states for any future projects if they want to use federal funds, but they don’t require immediate changes to existing guardrails.
But Pennsylvania is taking a more aggressive approach by moving ahead now on the end terminals and increasing the annual budget for guardrail replacement from $44 million a year.
“Addressing these needs is an important part of our maintenance work, but this program is over and above such ongoing issues as taking care of pavement needs,” Ms. Richards said in a news release.
Melissa Batula, PennDOT’s highway project chief, said in an interview that the guidelines for higher guardrails are designed to address taller vehicles and change the point of impact on them.
“A box truck has a higher level than it used to,” Ms. Batula said. “[The high guardrail] helps to keep the vehicle on the road.”
Ms. Batula said most motorists probably won’t notice any change in the new guardrails.
The state has adopted the new guidelines as the state standard, which means the higher guardrails also will be required on most municipal contracts because they usually follow state standards. The Pennsylvania Turnpike also will have to meet the new standards on future projects, but officials couldn’t be reached to say whether that agency will upgrade any existing guardrails.
On the interstates, the plan calls for installing a new 50-foot-long transition piece to replace the end of the existing guardrail unless the entire section is being replaced, Ms. Batula said.
Nationally, some states began requiring the new guidelines before they went into place July 1, but few have taken the aggressive approach Pennsylvania is following by replacing existing end terminals, said Kelly Hardy, program manager for safety at the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials.
She works with the national association’s committee that recommends research used to update safety guidelines.
The guidelines are part of the Manual for Assessing Safety Hardware, which previously had been updated in 2009. They are designed to protect motorists by preventing rollovers or penetration when vehicles hit guardrails.
Nationally, several manufacturers have been defendants in lawsuits resulting from accidents in which vehicles have become impaled or metal from the guardrail split and went through the vehicle.
Pennsylvania quit using one of the controversial products, X-Lite end terminals manufactured by Lindsay Corp. of California, in February. The state has 800 to 2,000 X-Lites still in use, but the state hasn’t had any fatal accidents related to them, PennDOT spokesman Rich Kirkpatrick said.
Pennsylvania and the association of highway officials said the new guardrail standards are not related to the lawsuits.
Tony Dorsey, manager of media relations for the national transportation officials, said the group set its first guidelines in 1962 and periodically updates them based on safety research. That research includes simulations and actual tests with crash dummies.
“Crash-test criteria has evolved and continues to evolve,” Mr. Dorsey said. “[The new guidelines] are not a reflection of anything other than the change in the size of vehicles.
“It has nothing to do with the lawsuits or anything like that. There will be additional changes and manuals in the future as we do additional testing.”
Pennsylvania has 9,700 miles of guardrails along 40,000 miles of state-maintained roads — 1,500 miles on interstates, 2,300 miles on the national Highway System that is not part of interstates and 5,900 miles on lower-volume state roads.
Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1470 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.