The Port Authority may hire a different firm to continue the design of the proposed Bus Rapid Transit system between Oakland and Downtown Pittsburgh.
The authority’s Performance Oversight Committee on Thursday recommended AECOM Technical Services Inc. for a $10.5 million contract for the next phase of design despite concerns from state Rep. Dom Costa, D-Morningside and an authority board member. Mr. Costa questioned whether it was wise to switch from CDM Smith Inc., the Boston firm that did the preliminary design, this late in the project.
Smith had a $2.4 million contract for the preliminary work — typically about 30 percent — of the project design. In this case, that included two years of work holding public meetings, choosing the preferred route for the system and preparing an application for federal funding for about half of the $195.5 million project.
When the authority sought bids for the next design phase, which would take the project to 60 percent of its final design, it received two proposals, one from AECOM and another from Michael Baker Inc., which had been a primary subcontractor for Smith, with Smith as a subcontractor. After an extensive evaluation process, a 10-member committee recommended AECOM for the contract.
“We’re switching mid-term. Why are they better than Baker?,” Mr. Costa asked. “To me, it’s important to get that project working” because the next application for federal funding is due in September.
Keith Wargo, the authority's assistant general manager for engineering and technical support, said AECOM scored better than Baker mainly because the company would assign more people to the project. There shouldn’t be any delay while the firm familiarizes itself with the project, he said.
Read More
“They put together a better work plan,” Mr. Wargo said. “I think they’re ready to hit the street.”
After initially wanting to table the contract until the committee’s next meeting in September, Mr. Costa agreed to recommend it for board approval next week with the assurance his concerns would be addressed by then.
Authority CEO Katharine Eagan Kelleman said it’s not unusual to hire different firms to design segments of a project.
“We have the great fortune of having two outstanding firms,” she said. “We had one firm do one part and now someone else will do the next segment. It’s a different scope of work.
“[Our evaluation] is a good, solid process. I have complete faith in that process.”
The proposed system would use electric vehicles on exclusive lanes, outbound on Forbes Avenue and inbound on Fifth Avenue, to move riders between two of the state’s busiest business centers as frequently as every 3.5 minutes during rush hours. The Uptown neighborhood between Oakland and Downtown also would be upgraded from sidewalk to sidewalk as part of the project, which is scheduled to begin operation sometime in 2021.
Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1470 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.