As Americans hit the highways for vacation, they’re sharing the road with hundreds of thousands of trucks. Some of these trucks are owned and operated by large companies, others by smaller carriers.
The federal government’s systems for tracking data on the roughly 550,000 commercial motor carriers that traverse U.S. highways annually needs to be improved, if the goal is to prevent some of the 100,000 fatality or injury-causing crashes tallied each year, according to a report by a committee set up a year ago to study the issue.
“When we fly on airplanes, we believe that they’ve been inspected, they’re safe, that the government is watching out for our safety and the same thing’s true about trucks,” said Joel Greenhouse, a Carnegie Mellon University statistics professor.
Mr. Greenhouse co-chaired the 12-person National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine committee formed to conduct a Congressionally mandated study on the effectiveness of the methodology used by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. The agency regulates the safety of long-distance truck and bus carriers.
The committee has developed a set of recommendations meant to improve the collection and analysis of violations data.
Among the report’s findings are that the agency’s current safety measurement system works well to identify carriers at high risk for crashes, but could be improved with more consistent collecting of data from carriers and a statistically based model to better analyze the data.
“We thought that the logic and the elements of what they’re currently using were good, but the methods were not really rigorously scientifically based,” Mr. Greenhouse said.
Currently, the agency relies on the logical association between unsafe company practices and potential vehicle crashes to evaluate carriers and prevent accidents.
The agency runs data from inspections, usually done by law enforcement on the road, through an algorithm to decide how safe carriers are based on the number of violations that a truck or bus accumulates over time and the number of accidents they have.
There are 890 possible violations of safety regulations across six categories: unsafe driving, hours of service compliance, vehicle maintenance, controlled substances and alcohol use, hazardous materials compliance and driver fitness. If the agency determines that a carrier has too many violations, it will intervene with tactics including warning letters and government investigations.
About 3.5 million commercial motor vehicle roadside inspections are conducted each year, mostly by law enforcement or company inspectors. But some carriers might not be regularly conducting these inspections, let alone collecting and reporting their results.
Sharon-Lise Normand, a professor of biostatistics at Harvard’s T.H. Chan School of Public Health who co-chaired the committee, said the agency should work with states and other organizations to gather more consistent data on crashes, vehicle miles traveled by state and month and violations issued by state.
“Some of the largest companies out there are very familiar with all of their data and how this algorithm works, and probably analyze their data each month,” said committee member Brenda Lantz, associate director of the Upper Great Plains Transportation Institute. “But small owner/operators might not even know this exists.
“That’s the thing with the trucking industry — it’s so diverse, there are so many small mom-and-pop companies that don’t have resources to spend time on this.”
The committee’s 117-page report recommends the adoption of a system known as an “item response theory model.” Mr. Greenhouse compared it to standardized testing, where students answer multiple questions and are assigned a score based on their answers.
In the case of truck operators, the nearly 900 possible safety violations would serve as test questions, and a carrier’s “responses” would indicate a measure of the company’s safety culture.
The committee presented its report to Congress on June 26, recommending the gradual move to the new model over the next two years, a goal that agency representatives say they plan to pursue.
Randi Hutchinson, chief counsel at the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, said the agency has 120 days to prepare an action plan to present to Congress and the Office of the Inspector General. It has already begun that process by reaching out to Congressional staffers of members of the transportation committee and speaking with stakeholders — on the industry side, as well as safety advocacy groups and state enforcement partners.
One of the stakeholders involved is the American Trucking Associations, the largest national trade group for the industry, which encompasses 50 affiliated state trucking associations and industry-related conferences and councils.
Sean Garney, director of safety policy for the trucking association, said the report was needed in response to concerns and criticisms from within the industry, and the association hopes the agency takes the recommendations seriously.
Rachel Treisman: rtreisman@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1936 or on Twitter: @rachel_treisman.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.