The Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission’s decision last week to review all construction projects came two months after the majority of the five-member board approved a $5.7 billion, 10-year capital plan over the objections of the chairman and vice chairman.
The majority say that they were aware of potential financial shortfalls but the capital plan is a necessary working document that should be passed every two years and that it can adjusted as situations change. PennDOT Secretary Leslie Richards, who is a member of the commission, said in a statement that a capital plan is important to bond-rating agencies.
“Rating agencies want to see that we are properly maintaining our asset,” she said. “… I am not surprised and expected us to take a look at future construction projects to see what may need to be deferred and that is exactly what we plan to do now.”
Board chairman Sean Logan, who with vice chairman William Lieberman voted against the plan, said he “couldn’t in good conscience” vote for the plan knowing the agency likely wouldn’t have the money to pay for all of the projects. The capital budget includes normal maintenance, highway widening work and new construction such as the Lafayette Street exit near Philadelphia and the Scranton beltway.
The commission last week voted to raise tolls for the ninth consecutive year and members agreed to revisit all construction projects to make sure they are necessary and affordable despite approving the capital plan May 17.
The agency also is lobbying the state Legislature to eliminate a $450 million annual payment it must make to PennDOT to help fund public transit through 2023, when the payment is reduced to $50 million annually.
Partially because the commission has to borrow money to make the PennDOT payment, its annual debt service payments account for $600 million of its $980 million budget, a debt ratio Mr. Logan said is not sustainable.
“How could we vote for [the capital budget]?” Mr. Logan said. “I understand capital budgets are a piece of paper and can be changed. However, we have to be honest with the public.
“I couldn’t in good conscience vote for a document that is two or three or four times as much as we can afford.”
Mr. Lieberman said he agreed that the agency “didn’t have the financial ability to fund many of those projects.”
Asked what changed since the commission approved the capital plan, Mr. Logan said he believes other members saw the financial warning signs that he has been voicing for the past two years.
“I think the other commissioners saw what we saw,” he said. “I think we were all in agreement that the right thing to do is review all of the projects.
“I felt strongly that it was important to signal our concerns to our executive staff at the turnpike commission.”
Pat Deon, chairman of the Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority and a member of the turnpike commission, said in a statement that he understands concerns about financing the capital plan. But he said parts of the highway are still original construction and the agency has an obligation to make improvements.
“We do recognize why other commissioners would vote against the plan,” Mr. Deon said. “In view of our debt and other fiscal obligations, there is unquestionably a degree of uncertainty as to whether or not the commission will be able to fully fund the plan at its current level, especially in the out years.”
Mr. Deon said that’s why it is important to persuade the Legislature to eliminate the $450 million annual payment to PennDOT. Ms. Richards said the state must find another source for the money, calling it “a critical need for public transit funding that is helping transit agencies buy the buses and other equipment they need to serve more than 400 million rides a year across the state. Any proposal to eliminate such an important source of transit resources must be carefully weighed.”
The commission’s fifth member, Barry Drew, voted for the capital plan but couldn’t be reached for comment.
Mr. Logan expects the project review to take 30 to 60 days.
Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1470.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.