At a hearing Downtown on Wednesday, an attorney for the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission’s enforcement arm said Uber’s refusal to comply with repeated orders from judges showed it was unfit to operate in the Commonwealth.
Michael Swindler, a prosecutor with the PUC bureau of investigation and enforcement, stopped short of asking administrative law judges to revoke the San Francisco ride service company’s two-year experimental license, but recommended civil penalties in the amount of $19 million.
“In my two-plus decades in practice, I have never seen this level of blatant defiance,” Mr. Swindler said. Uber continued to operate in Allegheny County when a cease-and-desist order was in effect last summer, and did not respond to repeated requests from the PUC enforcement arm to provide information about the number of trips it conducted during that time.
Mr. Swindler said Uber lacks fitness to operate as a good corporate citizen. “The PUC needs to send Uber a $19 million message,” he said.
Uber attorney Karen Moury countered that since it moved into the Pittsburgh area in February 2014 — and received its emergency temporary authority that July — the company has been a model public utility. “[Uber] has worked to fit its new technology into an antiquated framework,” Ms. Moury said, and added that the PUC’s enforcers had failed to establish what violations Uber had committed.
Uber spokesman Jon Feldman testified that the company's trip data was a “key performance indicator" so secret that even some company employees can't access it. Uber is concerned the data could be used by competitors to plan strategies for pricing and promotions.
Read More
That trip data was the basis of the hearing. Uber provided the trip data to the PUC as part of its compliance plan under the terms of the two-year experimental license it received in January. But the data is under seal, and the enforcement bureau does not have access to it.
The experimental license allows Uber to operate everywhere in Pennsylvania that the PUC has jurisdiction over taxis and ride share companies, which only excludes Philadelphia.
The Philadelphia Parking Authority has banned Uber and its largest competitor Lyft, which both pair drivers using their own vehicles with customers via smartphone apps in cashless transactions. Both continue to operate there as well.
There is no timeline for the judges to issue their recommendation, but Judge Mary Long said revoking Uber’s two-year license remained on the table.
PUC spokeswoman Robin Tilley said any judges’ recommendation would require a vote by the full board of commissioners to take effect. The commissioners have voted against the judges’ recommendations on Uber and Lyft in the past.
Kim Lyons: klyons@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1241. On Twitter: @SocialKimly.
Kim Lyons: klyons@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1241. On Twitter: @SocialKimly.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.