Pennsylvania has improved its highway safety laws over the past five years but still falls short of the recommendations of a national safety advocacy organization.

In a report issued today, Advocates for Highway & Auto Safety gave the state a middling grade, saying it has eight of 15 recommended laws in place. That’s an improvement from 2010, when Pennsylvania was one of nine states found to be “dangerously behind” in enacting safety laws.

Since then, the Legislature has enacted a ban on texting while driving, an improved booster seat law, and tighter regulations on teen driving, including a limit of one passenger other than immediate family for beginning drivers.

The report, “Lethal Loopholes,” gave 10 states its highest rating, green, for significant progress on highway safety legislation. Pennsylvania was among 31 states rated yellow, meaning the “state is advancing but has numerous gaps in its highway safety laws.” Nine states received a red rating, signifying “a dangerous lack of basic safety laws.”

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania barely avoided inclusion in the bottom grouping and risks falling back if it doesn’t take additional steps to improve safety, said Jackie Gillan, president of the Washington, D.C.-based organization, an alliance of consumer, medical, public health and safety groups and insurance companies.

Chief among the group’s recommendations for the state was making failure to wear a seat belt a primary offense for all passengers in a vehicle. The existing law requires drivers, front-seat passengers and those under 18 to buckle up, but adult drivers can be cited only if they are pulled over for another infraction.

“When you have secondary enforcement, you won’t get people to buckle up and it ties the hands of the police,” Ms. Gillan said in an interview Wednesday.

The report faulted Pennsylvania for not requiring motorcyclists to wear helmets. The Legislature repealed the helmet law in 2003, an action Ms. Gillan called “absolutely criminal.” At present, 19 states and the District of Columbia require helmets.

Twenty-four states now require all DUI offenders to use ignition interlock devices, which test a driver’s breath for the presence of alcohol before a vehicle can be started. Pennsylvania is not one of them, requiring the devices only for repeat offenders.

Advertise with us

A bill to extend the requirement to first-time offenders was approved Wednesday by the state Senate Transportation Committee. Similar legislation has cleared the Senate previously but not the House.

The report said Pennsylvania should strengthen its ban on night driving by teens to span the 10 p.m. to 5 a.m. period. The current state law spans 11 p.m. to 5 a.m. and exempts those traveling to or from work or charitable service. The report also said the state should not allow anyone younger than 18 to receive an unrestricted license and ban all cell phone use, including hands-free, by teen drivers.

Closing loopholes in safety laws should be a top priority of the state’s new governor, Tom Wolf, and the Legislature, Ms. Gillan said. “None of these should be heavy lifts. The public really supports these laws, and they have bipartisan appeal.”

Pennsylvania had 1,208 traffic fatalities in 2013, down from 1,310 the year before. Highway deaths in the U.S. have generally declined over the past decade, falling from 43,510 in 2005 to 32,719 in 2013.

“There are still far too many people being needlessly killed and injured on our roads,” Ms. Gillan said. “We are not making the progress we should be making in reducing deaths and injuries across the country.”

Advertise with us