Drivers of two Port Authority buses appeared to be racing and jockeying for position before their buses collided on the Parkway North, sending one of them over a hillside, investigators said Wednesday.
Port Authority police charged Thomas Frauens, 56, of Brookline, and Juliann Maier, 46, of Ross, with multiple offenses in connection with the Sept. 22 crash that left Ms. Maier badly injured.
Mr. Frauens, an authority employee since 2002, was charged with leaving the scene of an accident involving serious injury, a third-degree felony; a second count of failing to remain at the scene of an accident with vehicle damage; four counts of reckless endangerment; speeding; careless driving; reckless driving; and failure to notify police.
Mrs. Maier, who was hired by the authority in 2000, was charged with four counts of reckless endangerment, failure to remain in a traffic lane, speeding, careless driving and reckless driving.
Leaving the scene of an accident with vehicle damage and reckless endangerment are misdemeanors; the rest of the lesser charges are summary offenses.
A criminal complaint filed in support of the charges, using witness reports and footage from five surveillance cameras aboard Mr. Frauens’ bus, said the incident began when the two entered the southbound parkway shortly after 2 p.m. after leaving the Ross Garage to begin their routes. No passengers were aboard either vehicle.
Read More
The video showed Mr. Frauens removing his right hand from the steering wheel and gesturing toward Mrs. Maier, including a “buggy whip” motion, as his bus accelerated and passed her on the left between the McKnight Road and Venture Street interchanges.
Mrs. Maier’s bus then accelerated and passed Mr. Frauens on the right, then swerved toward his vehicle three times in a matter of seconds, forcing him onto the left berm. The third time, the buses struck each other, and Mrs. Maier’s bus went out of control and crashed, the complaint said.
The buses were traveling about 65 mph in a 55-mph zone at the time of the crash, according to surveillance and tracking equipment.
Witnesses who were driving on the parkway at the time “indicated that the buses appeared to be either racing, jockeying for position, or trying to pass and catch up to one another,” the complaint said.
One witness told police he was so concerned about the racing and jockeying that he took evasive action before the crash, according to the complaint. Mrs. Maier’s bus narrowly missed striking another vehicle as it veered out of control across the parkway.
After the crash, Mr. Frauens stopped on the berm and left his bus for about eight minutes before returning to it and driving off. Contacted later by investigators, he estimated his speed at 40 mph and denied that the buses collided, according to the complaint. Investigators found fresh damage, including a cracked window, on Mr. Frauens’ bus and later verified with garage surveillance video that the damage occurred after the bus left the garage. Each bus was marred with paint from the other vehicle.
Mr. Frauens told investigators he left the crash scene and continued his route after seeing that others had come to the aid of Mrs. Maier, whose bus pierced the guardrail, rolled down a hill and came to rest on its side on Evergreen Avenue.
An extensive review of phone calls, radio communications and 911 recordings determined that neither driver reported the crash, the complaint said.
Lawyers for both drivers have denied any misconduct. Attorney Joel Sansone, representing Mrs. Maier, has alleged that the crash was caused by a mechanical problem and that the authority was covering it up -- including that Port Authority police deleted photos of the scene taken by an eyewitness of the crash. Bruce Carsia, Mr. Frauens’ lawyer, said he was surprised that any charges were filed.
“It’s our belief that this was an accident, that Julie lost control of her bus, went through the guardrail and down the embankment,” Mr. Carsia said. “Mr. Frauens didn't have anything to do with her crashing her bus.”
It wasn’t Mr. Frauens, or Mrs. Maier, but rather the Port Authority itself that caused the accident, by sending out a faulty bus that shook so badly when driven that a request was made earlier that day to remove it from service, Mr. Sansone said.
After the accident, “innumerable” bus drivers called his office to say that the bus was a “rolling death trap,” he said.
“My client’s life is ruined because someone at the Port Authority allowed my client to drive a bus that was dangerous, out in public,” said Mr. Sansone, who said Mrs. Maier suffered broken ribs, broken pelvis, broken leg, broken finger, multiple cuts requiring stitches, and abrasions that left her black and blue.
She is confined to a wheelchair for now, he said.
The facts of the case -- which include statements to him from two eyewitnesses who say Mrs. Maier and Mr. Frauens were not engaging in horseplay, and the crash was preceded by violent shaking from Mrs. Maier’s bus -- shows his client’s innocence, Mr. Sansone said.
Her husband, Ron Maier, called the charges against his wife a tragedy.
“Very upsetting, devastating, can’t believe it,” Mr. Maier said, describing his reaction to hearing that his wife had been charged. “It’s ridiculous -- she did nothing wrong.”
In a statement, district attorney spokesman Mike Manko defended the charges and the investigation by Port Authority police.
"This was a thorough and complete investigation and the affidavit sets forth a number of reasons, including objective video evidence, detailing why the charges were filed," he said. "The truth of this matter will play out in a court of law and not in the media."
According to the criminal complaint, accident investigators from the Port Authority and Pittsburgh police found a broken tie rod on Mrs. Maier’s bus but concluded that it was sheared off as the bus rolled over. It had no scratches, scrapes or marks to indicate that it broke before the bus went out of control.
“All critical inspection areas were inspected to see if they were possible contributing factors to the crash. No defects were discovered,” it said.
No date has been set for preliminary hearings. Both drivers remain on paid leave pending internal disciplinary proceedings.
In a statement, Port Authority spokesman Jim Ritchie said the complaint “speaks for itself. For now, we decline to comment further as the two employees involved have certain rights under our labor contract and we must respect that process."





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.