Port Authority has named its real-time bus tracking system TrueTime and has implemented tracking on 41 of its 98 bus routes, with 10 more scheduled to be active on Friday.
For now, though, the system is falling a bit short of providing the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.
The system is supposed to let riders know to the minute when a bus will reach a certain stop. Two days of sampling at Downtown stops by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette found some flaws.
The biggest: Lots of buses that are supposed to be tracked are not appearing in the system. In a 20-minute period on Monday, four buses arrived at Fifth Avenue and Wood Street without appearing on the screen that lists expected arrival times.
During Tuesday’s morning rush, six buses arrived at the stop in a 10-minute span without appearing in the tracking system.
“We are aware of some operators who are not properly logging in to the system when driving the bus, which causes them to not appear on the system,” authority spokesman Jim Ritchie said. “We are working with each division to emphasize the importance of this step.”
Read More
Also, some older buses that will be removed from service next year will not get the hardware for tracking, and about a dozen new vehicles, with bus numbers in the 6000s, have not yet been equipped but will be next month, he said.
Riders have long clamored for real-time information about bus arrivals, and the authority has a goal of having nearly all routes on the system by the end of the year, with tracking of rail vehicles coming next year.
The system allows users of computers and mobile devices to view a list of impending arrivals for bus stops or routes. The information is updated every 30 seconds.
The website also has maps that display the locations of buses at any given time.
The tracking system seemed to work well for the buses that were displayed. The Post-Gazette found no instance where a bus that was listed on the system failed to show up.
But there were a few other hiccups.
One bus, a 71D Hamilton, left Fifth and Wood on Monday while the TrueTime system said it was still two minutes away from arriving.
Two other buses, a 61C McKeesport-Homestead and 61D Murray, were shown to be approaching Fifth and Wood on Tuesday morning, but the information vanished from the system when they were a block away from reaching the stop.
A 28X Airport Flyer was listed as “approaching” a stop at Liberty Avenue and Wood but did not arrive until four minutes later, and the information vanished from the system while it was still a block away.
At a stop on Grant Street, a P1 East Busway-All Stops pulled up while the system said it was still two minutes away. The system changed the bus’s status to “approaching” just as it pulled away.
The system said a Y1 Large Flyer was approaching the stop on Fort Pitt Boulevard near Smithfield Street on Tuesday morning, but when it arrived, the head sign had been switched to “West Mifflin Garage,” indicating it was out of service.
Mr. Ritchie said the system is designed to learn as it goes along, incorporating information from past experience into the projections it makes. “It’s not always going to be exact,” he said.
The system can be accessed by visiting the authority’s website, www.portauthority.org, or with several smartphone apps that have been developed by outside entities.
A list of the apps is provided on the authority’s website at the “rider services” link near the top of the homepage.
Riders who responded to Post-Gazette inquiries on social media gave the system mixed reviews.
“It’s long overdue, I will say that first, and glad they’re getting it up and running before the winter. With that said it had serious reliability issues,” said rider Lenny James in an email.
“Buses aren’t showing up on the tracker, making one think there are huge gaps in service.”
Other comments, posted on Facebook, included these:
“Despite only being on a few routes, and not working on every bus even on those, it’s still extremely useful. I’ve been accessing it via an Android app named Transit, which is far more convenient than accessing the new real-time info via PAT’s web site.” — Steven Doerfler
“If only there were more routes to follow.” — Carol Trapp Lorimer
“Yes, incredibly helpful, prevents lots of wasted waiting time. I can’t wait to not have to stand in cold waiting for a bus that came early or is 10+ minutes late.” — Brittany Gernhard
“We on the West-Southwest corridor get minimal service anyway. My son relies solely on public transport and is often disappointed. This app wouldn’t help him if there’s no alternate way to get to work.” — Anne Mulcahy
Jon Schmitz: jschmitz@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1868. Twitter: @pgtraffic.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.