The Penn Avenue reconstruction project in Garfield, described as “a comedy of errors” by one neighborhood leader, remains months behind schedule and has gone well over budget.
Four blocks of Penn Avenue have been torn up since August 2013 for work that includes street and sidewalk reconstruction and new trees, traffic signals and lighting. Work was scheduled to be completed this year, but the project will stretch into next spring, said Guy Costa, chief operations officer for city government.
The contractor, Matcon Diamond Inc. of the South Side, is working double shifts to try to complete the street reconstruction before winter sets in, he said. That will allow the city to restore two-way traffic on the street, which currently is open only to westbound vehicles.
Work on the sidewalks, signals and trees will be delayed until next year, he said.
Numerous problems have delayed the project and escalated the $4.7 million construction cost by at least $800,000, Mr. Costa said. “It could be more,” he said of the overrun.
Underground utilities were not shown on maps or were mapped inaccurately. Water lines broke. Old streetcar tracks were unearthed and the soil around them was found to be contaminated.
The project was meant to transform the streetscape on Penn from Mathilda Street to Evaline Street. But those who travel the corridor saw little construction activity for long stretches of time this year.
Rick Swartz, executive director of the Bloomfield-Garfield Corp., which worked for years to make the project a reality, said it has been plagued with problems and poor communication from the very start. “It has been a real disappointment,” he said.
The group was told the work would be done in two-block increments to minimize disruption.
“When the barricades went into place, we had a four-block project, right out of the gate,” he said. Another block was fenced off and used to store construction materials.
A water leak was detected at Mathilda in the spring but went unrepaired for 2½ months, he said. The city allowed the contractor to place a construction trailer on a vacant lot, then sold the land to private owners who demanded $1,000 per month to keep the trailer there. Drains had to be built to collect water that was seeping into the construction area.
Business owners who have suffered devastating losses during construction met with Mayor Bill Peduto last week, and the city and neighborhood group are trying to devise ways to help them, Mr. Swartz said.
“Some of them have spent their lives building their small businesses and now they’re watching it all wash out to sea,” he said. “Everybody’s trying to figure out how to lessen the damage.”
Jerry Kraynick, owner of a bicycle repair shop that has operated at 5003 Penn Ave. for 38 years, said his summer season was slower than usual. “In the middle of the summer, you never get caught up,” he said. “This summer I was caught up a lot. We’re doing OK in spite of it, but it’s affected everyone up here, some of them drastically.”
Mr. Kraynick faulted the contractor for understaffing the project. “If they hadn’t just lollygagged around, it would’ve been easier to take it,” he said.
He is concerned that his annual holiday campaign to collect and fix donated bicycles for underprivileged children will be affected. “It’s going to be difficult. I’m still going to do the program, and we’ll just have to manage.”
Work on the westbound side of Penn has been completed, and contractor crews were laboring last week to tear up and rebuild the eastbound side. “We’re seeing a lot more activity now than we saw in the months before,” Mr. Swartz said.
The group had hoped the project would be followed by a second phase to improve Penn from Evaline to Aiken Avenue, but some business owners in that section are recoiling. “Now we have to think, ‘How in the world do we sell people on phase two?’ ” he said.
“There’s probably going to be litigation [between the city and contractor] when this is all over,” Mr. Swartz said. “There’s been a lot of blame-placing and finger-pointing over the delays and escalating costs. People ask me where’s the blame going to fall for this. It’s probably going to fall on both sides of the fence.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.