Looming cuts in public transit service will cost the public far more than the $60 million that is needed to avert them, a community organization reported Friday.
Added commuting costs for transit riders and congestion costs for all drivers would total $328 million to $405 million per year, the Pittsburgh Community Reinvestment Group said. That figure does not include possible losses of businesses or residents that might occur if the Port Authority goes ahead with a planned 35 percent service cut Sept. 2.
"We've just finally turned the corner in Pittsburgh in terms of attractiveness to the outside world," said Chris Sandvig, the group's regional policy director. "Something like these service cuts could send us back in the other direction."
The group, which advocates increased state funding for transit, arrived at the figures using what it called conservative calculations based on statistics from the American Public Transportation Association, Texas Transportation Institute and Southwestern Pennsylvania Commission.
An estimated 15,000 transit riders who would lose their service would spend $60 million to $137 million more on commuting costs, it said. The public transportation association estimates transit riders save about $9,000 per year in commuting costs if they own one fewer vehicle as a result.
The Texas institute has estimated the cost of traffic congestion in the Pittsburgh urbanized area at $850 million annually. The SPC forecasts a 41 percent increase in congestion after the transit cuts. Adjusting for the degree of urbanization in Allegheny County, the added congestion cost would be $268 million a year, the community group said.
Additional costs estimated at $6.9 million to $15.5 million would be borne by residents of surrounding counties who are Port Authority riders. More than half of the users of the authority's Alpine Village park-n-ride in Monroeville are from outside Allegheny County. The 245-space lot would be closed Sept. 2 because the P12 Holiday Park Flyer route that serves it is scheduled for elimination.
Several other suburban park-n-ride lots also will close because of elimination of their bus service.
Another potential public cost would come if the city is required to build additional parking structures to accommodate increased demand. Adding 2,500 parking spaces would cost at least $50 million, the group said.
Other costs were incalculable, including the loss of young professionals who increasingly prefer not to own cars; loss of productivity; reduced competitiveness for the region; and the impact on the elderly and disabled, Mr. Sandvig said.
"We're talking about spending hundreds of millions of dollars for that $60 million in savings," he said. "And it hits you whether you drive or take the bus. Whether you live in the county or just across the border in Murrysville or Peters, it's going to hit you in the pocketbook."
The transit cuts were approved by the Port Authority board to close a projected $64 million budget deficit in the 2012-13 budget.
State and local officials and Amalgamated Transit Union Local 85, which represents transit drivers and mechanics, are in talks aimed at producing $60 million to $65 million in savings and additional funding to keep service levels intact.
The findings "clearly show in dollars and cents the damage that will be caused in this region by the 35 percent transit reduction scheduled to occur in September," Port Authority spokesman Jim Ritchie said. "This is why it's vital that we collectively find a lasting solution to the problems."



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.