Scott Rice said he was amused to read that the Legislature had stripped the Port Authority of its power to regulate public transit in Allegheny County and handed it to the state's Public Utility Commission, in what supporters billed as a way to increase competition.
Mr. Rice, who has been trying since October 2009 to be certified to operate limousines here, said from his perspective, the PUC process stifles competition rather than promoting it.
"It's just been an ongoing nightmare," he said. "It's a process that's so warped. A competitor can prevent other competitors from going into business."
He is operating under a provisional approval from the PUC, but Mr. Rice is upset that companies affiliated with a regional transportation giant were able to protest his application and that the matter remains unresolved some 21/2 years later.
"It's an interesting case," said Ray Middleman, attorney for Airport Limousine Service Inc., an affiliate of Pittsburgh Transportation Group, which also operates Yellow Cab, SuperShuttle and other services. "It's taken a long time to get to this point. It doesn't usually take this long."
Asked if Airport Limousine was trying to block a prospective competitor, Mr. Middleman said the company and its affiliates protested Mr. Rice's application so he would be required to demonstrate the technical and financial ability to properly serve the public.
Mr. Rice's original handwritten application said he intended to operate with one vehicle, a 2004 Cadillac, and one employee -- himself. He said he had no experience in providing transportation service but possessed a business degree. He said he foresaw acquiring more vehicles and drivers as the business grew.
"Since he had no track record, we protested," Mr. Middleman said.
That was in December 2009. By May 2010, Airport Limousine and Mr. Rice thought they had reached an agreement under which the protest would be dropped. Mr. Rice agreed not to serve Pittsburgh International Airport for five years.
It took another three months for the PUC to reject the deal, saying its purpose was to protect Airport Limousine's business interests and not to further the public interest. But in a decision Mr. Middleman described as "gracious," it allowed Mr. Rice to operate under the agreement pending further action.
Airport Limousine then demanded a hearing into Mr. Rice's fitness to operate. It was a full year later, in August 2011, that the five-member PUC voted to send the case to an administrative law judge. The judge began a hearing two months later, but Mr. Rice decided he needed a lawyer, so the proceeding was postponed for another two months.
The judge, Conrad A. Johnson, heard the case Dec. 6. As of last week, he had not rendered a decision.
"It just happens sometimes," said Mr. Middleman, who added that he has handled PUC cases for 28 years. "They get very busy. It ebbs and flows."
PUC spokeswoman Jennifer Kocher said she expected a decision in the matter "any day now." The commission handles 8,000 filings per year, she said, and limousine applications typically do not draw protests and are processed within six months.
When there is a protest, the procedures "can be frustrating" for applicants, Ms. Kocher acknowledged. "One of the ways we try to smooth that is by granting temporary authority" to operate, she said.
Mr. Rice said he now has four vehicles and two other drivers and his business, S&L Limousine Service, "is doing OK." But he still doesn't have a PUC certificate and isn't allowed to solicit business at the airport. He said he has spent $4,000 to $5,000 on lawyer fees and sees no end to the legal entanglement.
After the judge rules, the parties will be able to file exceptions that will be considered by the five-member PUC. After the PUC rules, either side can appeal to Commonwealth Court.
"This has nothing to do with my ability to perform," Mr. Rice said.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.