Like the wildebeests and zebras making their great migration together across the African plains, drivers and bicyclists set out each day to traverse Pittsburgh's urban landscape.

Generally, they travel side-by-side in peace, navigating winding slopes, narrow bridges and cavernous potholes as they make their way toward their daily destinations. But sometimes, sharing territory leads to trouble.

And last week, when a new law went into effect solidifying the rights of bicyclists, was one of those times.

News of the "Safe Passing" legislation awakened resentment between bicyclists and motorists, with a war of words breaking out on news organization websites and message boards. The Post-Gazette's story Monday drew more than 600 comments.

Advertise with us

"Any time any sort of step forward gets taken for bicycles, there's all this vitriol," said Scott Bricker, executive director of Bike Pittsburgh, a 10-year-old nonprofit organization supporting biking in Pittsburgh. "They take umbrage at the fact that someone who is more vulnerable than they are is getting more rights. It's just unbelievable."

In summary: Drivers resent bicyclists for slowing them down, for disobeying traffic laws, for acting superior because they're getting exercise while not paying for gas or parking -- not to mention for posting sanctimonious comments from places like Brooklyn and San Francisco.

And bicyclists: Well, they resent the fact that they could become road kill because a driver just had to glance at his phone to read a text message (also now illegal).

Roughly 1.6 percent of Pittsburghers commute primarily by bicycle each day, according to the U.S. Census -- a figure that is up 269 percent from 2000 and now ranks Pittsburgh 13th in the nation. Many, many more people commute occasionally or bike recreationally, said Mr. Bricker.

An increase in biking statewide was one factor behind the new law, which specifies that cars should pass a bike with a minimum of four feet of clearance space, prohibits the "classic right hook" in which a right turn by a motorist interferes with a bicyclist going straight and says that bicycles must use the right-hand lane, or as close as possible to the right edge of the roadway, unless road conditions are unsafe.

Advertise with us

The law was needed, say bicycle advocates, to raise awareness and to give injured bicyclists some recourse in the event of an accident.

But for some motorists, the law put them on the defensive, reminding them of all the instances in which they saw a cyclist breaking a law. "What about protection of the driver of the motor vehicle?" wrote Stephanie Capor of Pittsburgh. "I can't even tell you how many times a bike has cut me off, gone through a red light or not stopped at a stop sign. Bike riders think they can do whatever they want and NOT follow the traffic laws. They should be fined for going through red lights or stop signs."

Many drivers who commented complained about bicyclists who didn't stop at stop signs or red lights, noting that they didn't think it was fair that they should be held responsible for hitting a bicyclist if that bicyclist was acting irresponsibly. Others questioned whether it was realistic to allow bikers four feet of clearance space on some of Pittsburgh's narrow streets and bridges.

And some felt like the simple act of just riding a bike on a city street was inherently reckless.

"Some bike riders seem to know what laws pertain to them, but most don't," wrote Bonnie White. "I do not like when they ride in the middle of the lane going 10 miles an hour and get mad at you for saying anything. I can't believe how many of them trust that they won't get hit. They should value their life more than the right to ride in traffic. Just saying."

Advertise with us

The antipathy toward bicyclists goes beyond just Internet venting, said Aaron Stein, store manager at ProBikes in Squirrel Hill, who commutes from his home in Park Place by bike. On most rides of significant length, he'll hear at least one negative comment from a driver, he said.

If he's biking on a weekend wearing spandex, he'll hear gay slurs. Otherwise, he hears comments along the lines of "get off the road." He's been hit several times, though never seriously.

Friends of his haven't been so lucky -- two mechanics in his shop were injured in the last two weeks.

Larry Dones, a mechanic at Thick Bikes on the South Side, was injured so badly in a Downtown bike crash when he worked as a bike messenger several years ago that he needed five or six surgeries to repair his shattered pelvis. He nearly died in the accident and subsequent surgeries, and has permanent nerve damage in his right leg.

Drivers and bikers need to be understanding of each other, said Mr. Dones. Drivers need to be more patient and aware, and cyclists should not "hog up the whole road and hold up all of traffic just because you're allowed to be there."

Advertise with us

While cyclists and motorists both behave badly at times, Mr. Stein said that a law protecting bicyclists is much needed. "The big difference is that cars are the major mode of transportation," he said. "We're a minority, and we're more vulnerable."

As a cyclist, he tries to be respectful of drivers and to obey traffic laws, though he admits that it can be hard to come to a full stop at a stop sign in a residential neighborhood.

Pennsylvania law requires bicyclists to stop at stop signs and red lights, said Mr. Bricker, and prohibits them from riding on the sidewalks in business districts.

Bicyclists get flak for breaking laws in large part because they are so visible standing out from the norm, he said. "When I see a bike rider doing something really, really stupid, I cringe," he said. "At the same time, I want to ask motorists not to be so indignant about this, not to say that you don't break the law all the time. There are so many thousands of motorists out there breaking the law that it just becomes background noise."

Mr. Bricker said that Bike Pittsburgh is trying to focus on what can be done practically to improve biker-motorist relations, as well as bicyclist safety. He stresses safety lights for bike riders at night, as well as education and awareness. Bike Pittsburgh has a Bike Commuting 101 resource on its website and has handed out free bike lights and more than 100,000 copies of the Pennsylvania vehicle code.

Advertise with us

For his part, he believes that relations between motorists and bicyclists have improved dramatically in the past 10 years, in part because so many more motorists now bike recreationally. But the increase in bikers has also brought the issue more to the forefront.

"The silver lining is that all these comments on both sides just show how important this subject is," he said. "It's not a trivial subject. It's a real problem that needs to be solved."