The 60-year-old woman charged with killing her partner in Cumberland County 11 years ago tried to order a $10,000 hit on the victim a few months before she killed him, police said.

Betty Jane Adams, 60, of South Carolina, was charged with first degree and third degree murder in the May 1, 2015, shooting death of John Wesley Alleman Jr., who was 68 years old. The pair was living together at the time.

Here’s how the investigation played out, according to the affidavit of probable cause filed against Adams:

Adams’ daughter called 911 around 6:57 a.m. on May 1, 2015, to report a suicide at 60 Hickorytown Road in Middlesex Township.

Advertise with us

Police arrived and found Alleman dead in bed with a gunshot wound to the head. Adam’s daughter and her 11-year-old granddaughter were downstairs in the basement at the time of the shooting, police said.

Alleman was on his left side in bed with a gunshot wound on the right side of his head, covered in a sheet and a bed spread. A pillow was under his head, and his left arm was extended out to his left, partially covered with the sheets.

His right arm was bent, tucked up against his head and pillow with his hand partially under the sheet. Police said the position is inconsistent for Alleman to have fired the gun with his right hand.

Police found a stainless-steel Smith and Wesson .38 revolver on the dresser inside the bedroom door. Adams, who went by Betty Jane Brooks at the time, told police she used a towel to move the gun from the bed to the dresser to stop the pair’s dog from causing an accidental discharge, police said.

At the scene, Adams told police she lived off and on with Alleman for the past 10 years. Cumberland County District Attorney Séan McCormack said he believed Adams and Alleman were romantic partners.

Advertise with us

The night of the shooting, Adams told police she slept on the living room recliner while Alleman slept in the bedroom.

She told police between 5:30 and 6 a.m., she went to the bathroom and Alleman called out to her. When she went into the bedroom, Alleman complained about his life and expressed animosity toward her.

Adams told police she was sitting at the foot of the bed when Alleman got a gun from under the covers and fired at her, saying she thought the bullet hit the wall.

She said she told Alleman he “could not do that” and she was going to call police, then he reportedly said he knew people in high places and would not face consequences.

Adams told police Alleman then shot himself and she was unable to reach him in time, although she tried to intervene.

Advertise with us

Adams later told a deputy coroner she was standing in the bedroom doorway when she was shot at, which was different from where she told police she was, according to the affidavit.

Adam’s daughter told police she heard two gunshots, about one or two minutes apart, and came up from the basement when Adams came down the hallway telling her to call 911.

Adams had gunshot residue on both of her hands, suggesting she recently handled or discharged a firearm.

Police looked through the home but didn’t find a bullet hole or bullet linked to the reported first gunshot in Adam’s story. The coroner found one bullet in Alleman’s body and determined his cause of death was a gunshot wound to the head and was classified as a homicide.

Five days after the homicide, police got a call from Adams’ ex-husband’s current wife.

Advertise with us

She said in January or February 2015, Adams’ ex-husband got a text from an unknown number, which he identified as Adams because she frequently changed phone numbers, police said.

The text asked Adams’ ex-husband if he wanted to do a “hit” for $10,000. When he asked who sent the message, the response was, “Who do you think it is?”

He asked, “Are you crazy?” and in return, she asked “Do you know anyone who would do it?”

When Adams’ daughter called Adams’ ex-husband about the death, the ex-husband’s wife messaged Adams and said, “What a coincidence.”

Shortly after, Adam’s ex-husband got a text from Adams saying, “Tell your wife to keep her [expletive] mouth shut,” police said.

Advertise with us

Police and the district attorney’s office never told the public about the killing until Monday. The district attorney said they previously suspected Adams but didn’t have enough proof to charge. McCormack didn’t mention the texts about the proposed “hit” in his 11 a.m. news conference and wasn’t immediately available to answer questions about why the text messages and other evidence wasn’t enough to charge before now.

In April 2021, police again sought to interview Adams, and she told police she didn’t shoot Alleman.

Three years later, a forensic consultant did ballistic testing to determine the amount of recoil force that would’ve been directed at the operator’s hand when the gun found at the crime scene was fired: 5.15-foot pounds of force at a velocity of about 17.94 feet per second.

After reviewing crime scene photographs, a separate forensic analysis determined Alleman was shot from about 3 inches away.

Based on biomechanics and forensic analysis, the firearm’s recoil during a suicide would have made Alleman’s hand and arm to move backward, which would make it impossible for Alleman’s hand to be partially underneath the bed sheet. In addition, most firearm suicides are contact shots, meaning the barrel of the gun is against the victim’s skin, police said.