HARRISBURG — The Department of Human Services is dropping a bid to give some low-income parents a break on their day care bills, at least for now.
Instead, DHS is moving to keep in place a long-standing rule that allows day cares to charge low-income parents to make up for the difference between the state’s subsidy and the cost the facilities charge other parents.
DHS had submitted regulations to the Independent Regulatory Review Commission that included a provision axing the so-called “balanced billing” practice, but the agency backed down after pressure from the day care industry and other advocacy organizations, including the United Way.
In May, IRRC rejected a regulatory update, at DHS’s request, so that the agency could rework the regulations in light of the opposition.
The revised regulations submitted to IRRC in late July reinstate the balance billing provision while saying that DHS intends to compile data on the practice’s impact on low-income families and that the agency will hold stakeholder meetings to discuss the provision.
The new version of the regulations is on the agenda for the September IRRC meeting.
Read More
In its filing, DHS notes that the rules impact at least 83,000 children in 49,000 families and if the number of families seeking day care subsidies increases to pre-pandemic levels those numbers would increase to more than 100,000 children in 61,000 families.
DHS’ new submission “maintains the status quo,” said Jen DeBell, executive director of the Pennsylvania Association for the Education of Young Children which had lobbied for DHS to drop its move to bar balance billing.
“Restoring the provision to the status quo at this time ensures there are no economic or fiscal impacts to the regulated community, of which 70% are small businesses,” according to the documents submitted to IRRC by DHS.
While some advocacy organizations pressed to allow the day cares to continue the balance billing – saying that barring the practice could drive day cares out of business which would make day care even less accessible to families – other advocacy groups have long-pressed to get balance billing eliminated.
Families who get subsidies for day care are required to pay co-pays that are supposedly based on what they can afford.
Allowing day cares to charge more than the co-pay “undermines” the whole concept of having co-pays based on the parents’ ability to pay, said Peter Zurflieh, an attorney with the Community Justice Project in Harrisburg.
Families can qualify for subsidies if their income is less than 200% of the limits set by federal poverty guidelines. For a two-person family, that would be less than $39,440; for a four-person family that would be less than $60,000.
Under the balance billing rule, families paying $20 a week in co-pay may be asked by their day care provider to pay another $40-$100 a week on top of the amount the state determined the family can afford, Mr. Zurflieh said.
That can squeeze low-income families out of using high-quality day cares for their children while forcing them to seek less expensive alternatives, he said.
“In our view, (balance billing) makes a mockery of the co-pay scale,” Mr. Zurflieh said.
But the advocacy groups who’d pushed to keep balance billing asserted that eliminating the practice would have its own set of unintended consequences. Some day cares could be forced to close their doors and others may look to boost tuition rates for non-subsidy families if they can’t use balance billing to make up for the difference between the subsidy reimbursement and their normal rates.
Mr. Zurflieh said despite its opposition to the balance billing provision, Community Justice Project is not planning to ask IRRC to reject the regulations.
In part that is due to other beneficial regulations included in the package being submitted by DHS. Another factor is that DHS has promised to compile the data on the impact of balance billing and to hold the stakeholder discussions about the practice’s impact on low-income families.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.