HARRISBURG — One Penn State retiree collects $1.2 million in state pension benefits each year. Some former Pennsylvania state government and school employees are paid more in retirement than they ever earned while working.

At least 1,809 of these retirees are collecting more than $100,000 annually from Pennsylvania’s two state public pension systems, according to data PennLive received through a Right-to-Know request. The number of six-figure earners has almost doubled in the past eight years.

Of course, six-figure pensions are not the norm. The vast majority of the nearly 360,000 state or school retirees receive far less. Tens of thousands receive less than $1,000 a month; some less than $100.

But the big payouts are a reminder of generous pension benefits that once lured people into public service but, due to a series of risky decisions by policymakers, left the pension systems $66 billion short of being able to meet their obligations to current and future retirees.

Advertise with us

And that’s a burden for Pennsylvania taxpayers, who help pay for those pensions.

Taxpayers pay the employer contributions to the State Employees’ Retirement System and the Public School Employees’ Retirement System. Those payments total $7.4 billion in the current fiscal year, with the employers’ rate for state employee pensions set at 35.32% of payroll and the employer’s rate for the school employees’ pensions, which is split between the state and school districts, at 34%.

Read More

Employees themselves also must contribute a percentage of their pay — it varies from 5% to 9.3% — through payroll deduction. The rest of the money that flows into the two pension systems to help provide an income to retirees comes from interest earnings on the systems’ combined $110 billion in assets.

All of that funds a system that today pays school retirees an average of $26,842 annually, and pays retired state workers average annuities of between $25,017 and $31,331.

Growth in six-figure pension earners

Advertise with us

Since 2015, the first time PennLive looked at the top pension payouts, the number of retirees earning $100,000 or more a year has ballooned.

There were 995 retirees with pensions in the six-figure range in 2015, collecting a total of $120 million annually. In 2022, the combined annual cost of the 1,809 six-figure pensions is $223.6 million.

The number of pensioners receiving $100,000 a year or more may actually be higher. The state’s Right to Know Law allows state agencies to withhold records of those who have cited a specific threat to their personal safety and security if their information is disclosed.

Former Penn State President Rodney Erickson topped the list in 2015 with his $477,000 yearly pension. Today, his is the fourth-highest pension.

The person collecting the largest pension? George Andrews, a renowned mathematician who taught at Penn State for 58 years. His annual pension is $1.25 million.

Advertise with us

Rounding out the list’s top five is the late California University of Pennsylvania mathematics professor George Novak, who received $583,000 a year after 65 years of work, and Dr. John Simmons, who retired as a disability physician specialist with the Department of Labor & Industry after 46 years. He receives nearly $497,000 a year.

State Employees’ Retirement System spokeswoman Pam Hile said the rise in the number of six-figure pensioners reflects increases in the state’s total payroll, even as the number of workers has decreased. The employee count for all three governmental branches dropped from 109,000 in 2015 to 99,704 last year, an 8% decline.

The Public School Employees’ Retirement System’s Evelyn Williams suggested that higher pay may be similarly affecting that system, but she noted the retirement system doesn’t negotiate teacher contracts. She referred questions to those who do.

At the time of their retirement, many workers take all or a portion of the money they contributed to the system in a lump sum, with 4% interest compounded annually, in return for lower monthly pension payments.

As a result of a 2017 law change, lump sum withdrawals are an option available to any retiree in the systems’ defined benefit (guaranteed pension) plan. Some 63% of state retirees and about 75% of school retirees take that option.

Advertise with us

Retirement pays

Nearly half of the top pension-getters last worked for one of five agencies:

State System of Higher Education (253)

Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts (174)

Pennsylvania State University (172)

Advertise with us

Philadelphia School District (112)

Department of Human Services (63)

The list of those receiving pension benefits above $100,000 includes retired school superintendents, state agency executives, university presidents and judges. But not everyone on the list was a top earner during their careers.

Rather it was the length of their careers and other factors, such as overtime, payouts for unused leave time, and cost-of-living adjustments that bumped up their retirement compensation.

In some cases, the incomes of former public servants rose considerably in retirement.

Advertise with us

For example, a former county assistance office employee, Dorothy Dill, had a final average salary (the average of her three highest-paid years) of $44,277. After working for more than 50 years, she now receives annual pension benefits nearly seven times that amount, $304,308.

A former highway toll collector, Chester Detweiler, had a final average salary of $54,653 when he retired after more than 62 years of work. His annual pension benefit is $249,891.

Ms. Hile of the State Employees’ Retirement System said factors that make retirement more lucrative than working include an age 70 supplement (the older the retiring person is, the larger the supplement) or joining the pension system before March 1974, when a benefits cap was imposed that limits annual pension payments to no more than a retiree’s highest compensation year.

Regardless of the reasons, David Draine, senior researcher for Pew Charitable Trusts said it’s important to remember these retirees are simply receiving benefits they were promised when they took their public sector job.

“There’s nothing wrong with a worker taking the deal that he or she got when they started public service and benefitting from it after decades of work for the state and school districts,” he said, adding: “It’s policymakers’ job to make sure that the benefits being offered are affordable and sustainable.”

Advertise with us

Funding those pension benefits

Affordability has been a challenge for the two state pension systems. A $20 billion surplus in 2001 prompted state lawmakers to eliminate the employer contributions — the portion paid by taxpayers — to the pension systems for a number of years.

That decision helped turn the hefty surplus into a $61 billion deficit by 2015. To date, the more than $80 billion swing over a 15-year period remains the largest recorded by any state, according to Pew Charitable Trusts.

Pennsylvania’s policymakers have since made adjustments to the public pension systems in an effort to deal with what is now $66 billion in unfunded liabilities. One change was to return the retirement systems to a 10-year vesting period in 2017 after it had been lowered to five years in 2001.

In 2019, lawmakers restructured the plans for newly hired school employees and most new state government workers, eliminating the guaranteed pension that had helped make public service a more attractive career.

Advertise with us

The exception is law enforcement and public safety employees such as police, corrections officers, game wardens and park rangers. They are allowed to remain in the guaranteed pension plan — also referred to as defined benefits — because state police don’t collect Social Security, and other hazardous-duty employees’ careers are typically shorter than those of most state employees.

Other employees hired during or after 2019 may choose from a hybrid plan that combines a defined benefits plan with a defined contributions plan, similar to a 401(k) plan, or a straight defined contribution plan, similar to what most private sector companies now offer. State and school employees contribute a mandatory 7.5% or 8.25% of their pay toward their pension, depending on the plan they choose. Those in the defined contribution plan can elect to contribute more.

Other changes made in 2019 include raising the retirement age for new employees from 65 to 67 and calculating pension benefits by averaging the five highest years of compensation rather than the three highest years.

Pension system officials said it’s too soon to know how those changes will affect pensions of future retirees.

A Pew analysis estimates that, on average, career government workers covered by the new hybrid plans can expect their retirement income to replace more than 90% of their final salary when including Social Security. Longevity in public service also will continue to affect the size of annuities.

Advertise with us

For those stewing after learning of these six-figure pensions that a small percentage of public retirees are receiving, experts say they should remember those employees’ retirement income is not what caused the pension systems to accumulate so much debt over the past two decades. That blame falls on state policymakers’ decisions to make no employee contributions for sustained periods and to enhance benefits, mixed with economic downturns.

“We look at what Pennsylvania has gone through and the challenges there because policymakers did retroactive benefit increases [in 2001], failed to make pension payments and didn’t have the tools to manage risk,” said Mr. Draine, of Pew Charitable Trusts. “What we expect and hope is that a lot of the changes as well as lessons learned from the past 20 years will help Pennsylvania have a sustainable plan going forward.”