HARRISBURG — Gov. Tom Wolf used an executive order to create the position of child advocate almost four years ago, but lawmakers and the current child advocate want the General Assembly to pass legislation to formally establish the office and spell out its authority.

Mr. Wolf’s 2019 executive order created the child advocate position within the Office of Advocacy and Reform. At the end of Mr. Wolf’s term in office, the other staff in the Office of Advocacy and Reform all left to take other jobs within the Shapiro administration. Only the child advocate remains.

“We don’t have an Office of Child Advocate. We have a child advocate doing everything she can to create an office,” said MaryAnn McEvoy, who has been the state’s child advocate since the summer of 2021.

During her tenure, she’s been working to help officials within the Wolf administration and now the Shapiro administration, as well as lawmakers and county officials, understand how the child advocate can effectively help improve the child protection system.

Advertise with us

“I will not play a blame game,” she said. “I came in to collaborate not to create gotcha moments,” Ms. McEvoy said.

Ms. McEvoy said there have been occasions where she’s sought information from the Department of Human Services but been denied access to it because the agency’s lawyers questioned whether she was authorized to view it.

At another point, the state notified counties that Ms. McEvoy should be included in reports made to child fatality review teams, but only four counties have been complying with that request.

Those are the kind of issues that the proposed legislation could resolve, said Cathleen Palm, director of the Center for Children’s Justice.

“You have a child advocate on staff but we don’t know what she’s authorized to do (now),” Ms. Palm said.

Advertise with us

House Bill 813 clearly specifies what the duties of the child advocate should be including:

-- Serving as an “independent resource to and advocate for children”;

-- Conducting both announced and unannounced visits to children and youth facilities and interview staff and residents of those facilities;

-- Receiving and reviewing complaints from the public, including complaints from juveniles, related to health, safety and well-being program processes and procedures and to make recommendations or referrals based on those complaints;

-- Reporting directly to the General Assembly about issues impacting the health, safety and well-being of children including concerns arising from the “design or implementation” of public policies, systemic practices or public investments;

Advertise with us

-- Serving on all child fatality or near fatality review teams;

-- Coordinating educational programs for public awareness about child abuse;

-- And working with the governor’s office, state agencies and lawmakers to review laws and policies impacting childhood trauma and work with state agencies to implement best practices to increase “healing-centered services” for vulnerable populations.

The legislation specifies that state and local agencies would be required to turn over documents sought by the child advocate within 10 days of a request by the advocate.

House Bill 813 also specifies that the appointment of the child advocate would be for a six-year term and that the appointment would require confirmation by the state Senate. The advocate would be eligible for reappointment.

Advertise with us

House Bill 813, sponsored by Rep. Christina Sappey, D-Chester, was introduced last week.

The House bill’s cosponsors include only Democrats but a cosponsor memo has been circulated in the Senate by Sen. Michele Brooks, R-Crawford, the chairwoman of the Health and Human Services Committee and three Democratic senators – Maria Collett, of Montgomery County; John Kane, of Delaware County; and Judith Schwank, of Berks County.

The Senate bill has not been formally introduced yet.

Ms. McEvoy said that while the bill could be changed as it moves through the Legislature, “I feel very good about where (HB 813) is.”

That legislation benefits from the fact that it included provisions based on perspective offered by youth and by those who’ve previously opposed legislation that would have created an Office of Child Advocate, she said.

Advertise with us

While Mr. Wolf created the child advocate position by executive order, efforts to get the position formalized in law have been stymied for years, in large part due to questions over how the office will interact and intersect with county oversight of children and youth programs.

A landmark 2012 report on potential reforms to child protection in Pennsylvania — an effort inspired by the Jerry Sandusky scandal at Penn State — did not recommend that the state establish a child advocate’s office because complaints about child protection can be made to county commissioners.

Both Ms. McEvoy and Ms. Palm pointed to Colorado as an example, however, of a state that has established a child advocate’s office while having child welfare programs run by counties. Officials in that state crafted their child advocate law after consulting with stakeholder groups in Pennsylvania who had been lobbying for the same thing here. Virginia, which also has a similar system of delivering child welfare programs through county agencies, has also created a child advocate’s office.

“The Ombudsperson or Child Advocate is the trusted place for youth and families to get information,” Ms. Palm said. Colorado’s program demonstrates how the office can “fully and proactively inform youth of their rights” and provide mechanisms for filing complaints and investigating them.

“When a family is separated from their children because the youth is placed in a mental health facility, a drug and alcohol treatment facility, foster care or a placement following an adjudication of delinquency, they, along with the youth, need to know who/where to call,” Ms. Palm said, adding that generally those families don’t trust the information coming from the people in the agencies that have removed their children from their homes.

Advertise with us

It’s not just a matter of concern for the families directly involved with the child protection system; there are fundamental questions about transparency and accountability when the agencies miss warning signs or otherwise fail to protect children in dangerous situations, Ms. Palm said.

She pointed to the tragic life and death of 12-year-old Max Shollenberger in Lebanon County as an example. Max’s naked and malnourished body was discovered in 2020 covered in human waste in bed in a room with no lights.

Max’s father Scott Shollenberger and his stepmother Kimberly Maurer were arrested in connection with the boy’s death. Scott Shollenberger pleaded guilty and was sentenced to life in prison. Maurer was convicted and sentenced to life in prison.

Initially county and state officials said there had been no reports made to Children and Youth about the family. But later, as the case went to trial, prosecutors cited hundreds of pages of child welfare documents shared with the jury, Ms. Palm said. The Department of Human Services’ eight-page public report on Max’s death entirely blocks out the passage detailing the “summary of circumstances prior to incident.” Elsewhere in that report an individual, whose identity is redacted, is quoted as having said they hadn’t seen Max since he was 3 or 4 years old but said they’d notified Lebanon County Children and Youth Services about the abuse in 2015. Later in the report, DHS noted that the county agency appeared to have been tipped off about the boy as early as 2014.

The section of the report describing the weaknesses in the county’s handling of the case is completely blacked out in the report released by DHS.

“We see this all the time,” Ms. Palm said. “The black ink in these reports renders them meaningless.”