When a Santa Fe, Texas, teenager opened fire at his high school in May, killing eight students and two teachers and wounding a dozen others, he used his father’s guns.

When it became clear that under Texas law the teen-age gunman’s father could not be prosecuted for giving his son access to the guns, some were outraged. Texas has a law that holds parents accountable if they allow their children access to their guns, but the law only applies to parents who leave firearms available to minors under 17. Dimitrios Pagourtzis, the accused shooter, was already 17 when he stepped into a Santa Fe classroom.

In Pennsylvania, a parent could be charged with providing guns to a child who is 17 or younger. According to state law, it is illegal for anyone under 18 to possess a firearm, but with a few exceptions including hunting and shooting competitions. Parents who provide guns to minors can be found guilty of a third-degree felony, which could result in up to seven years of jail time and a fine of up to $15,000.

But the Pennsylvania law contains a key provision that makes it less likely a parent would be charged, some experts say. Title 18 of the state crimes code does not penalize parents for recklessly leaving loaded weapons near unsupervised children. Instead, Pennsylvania parents have to “knowingly and intentionally” give a gun to a minor in order to violate the law.

Advertise with us

Twenty-seven states and Washington, D.C. have passed child-access prevention laws — legislation that makes it a crime for parents to recklessly leave guns around unsupervised children. Pennsylvania’s law does not fit this category.

The Pennsylvania law “is notably weak because the prosecutor would have to show that the parents provided the gun to the minor,” said Ari Freilich, a staff attorney and California Legislative Affairs Director at the Giffords Law Center to Prevent Gun Violence. “Maybe that’s why you see fewer prosecutions for this in Pennsylvania.”

An exception to this pattern is the recent case of Lenora Ann Hendrix, the mother of Uniontown Area High School student. In January, her son allegedly threatened to shoot four of his classmates at the high school. When authorities searched the house, the found an assortment of guns in her son’s bedroom — weapons she said she let him keep to teach him responsibility and to “let him grow up,” according to a criminal complaint.

Authorities charged Ms. Hendrix with violating the child gun law. At a June 11 hearing in Fayette County Common Pleas Court, a judge placed her into an Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition program for six months. If she successfully completes it, she will avoid jail time and have the charge against her expunged.

Criminal cases against parents like Ms. Hendrix are rare, though. Pennsylvania’s Office of Attorney General has not seen a case involving this provision of Title 18 in recent years, a spokeswoman said. When asked about other cases involving the Pennsylvania law, Mr. Freilich said none immediately came to mind.

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania’s lack of a child-access prevention law does not mean that parents cannot suffer any consequences for negligently giving a child access to a gun, however. Parents could be sued in a civil case, if their conduct enabled a minor to harm someone else with a gun.

Or they could be charged with reckless endangerment — a misdemeanor. Authorities have historically used this law, among others, to punish negligent gun owners whose actions do not violate Title 18.

In 2016, a teacher in Chambersburg faced this charge after she forgot to take her loaded gun with her out of the bathroom and four students, ranging from six to eight years old, stumbled upon it. So did a Ford City man after he left his gun unsupervised and a boy accidentally shot a bullet into the neck of his half-brother in 2015.

But these penalties are not enough, said Shira Goodman, Executive Director of the gun control advocacy group CeaseFirePA. She said a child-access prevention law would both educate Pennsylvania residents about the importance of storing their guns safely and deter them from negligently giving children access to the weapons.

“We need to say to gun owners, ‘We need to be responsible. We need to be mindful in the home,’” she said.

Advertise with us

Efforts are underway to pass a child-access prevention bill, but it may not garner the support it needs to become law. State Rep. Tim Briggs, D-Montgomery, has introduced House Bill 1635, which would amend Title 18 and mandate that anyone who “knows or reasonably should know” that a minor is likely to get access to a gun must secure the weapon. Under the proposed law, failure to do so would be considered a crime — and if minors use the guns to seriously injure or kill someone, gun owners would face third-degree felony charges.

Mr. Briggs has introduced similar proposals since 2009, without success, he said. The latest bill is currently in committee.

“In the particular makeup on the Legislature, I don’t think it will be brought up for a vote,” he said. “I think Second Amendment activists have strong feelings against the bill.”

Still, he emphasized the need for his legislation and said the current law is inadequate.

“I think we need to do a much better job of keeping firearms out of the hands of kids,” he said. “Every couple of months I seem to read another story about a child who was playing with their dad’s gun or someone in the house’s gun that was in a drawer and a horrific accident happens. In those instances, no one gave the child a gun.”

Advertise with us

“As a parent, my kids mean a lot to me and if I was a gun owner I would think I would want to do everything to make sure they were safe,” he said.

Caroline S. Engelmayer: cengelmayer@post-gazette.com or on Twitter @cengelmayer13.