At a state budget hearing last month, the then-acting Human Services secretary, Teresa Miller, was asked a question by a legislator: “Is Medicaid health care or is Medicaid welfare?”

“Medicaid is health care,” Ms. Miller replied.

That question is at the heart of an ongoing legislative fight in Harrisburg.

And how legislators and other policymakers answer that question could have far-reaching impacts on the program, which covers millions of Pennsylvanians.

Advertise with us

Last week, the House Health Committee advanced a bill that would require “able-bodied” individuals in the Medicaid program to be employed or attending a job-training program, or complete 12 job-training program-related activities in a month. Many recipients, such as pregnant women, caregivers to children under age 6 and people with disabilities, would be exempt.

Following the vote, protesters in the room started to chant, “It’s health care, not welfare,” at legislators.

House Bill 2138 is expected to get a vote in the full House this week. It would require the state to apply to the federal government under Section 1115 of the Social Security Act to require work or training as a condition of Medicaid eligibility. Such work requirement waivers hadn’t been approved until very recently, but have been given the green light under the Trump administration.

Supporters say the bill is a common-sense way to encourage work, and similar requirements apply to other safety-net programs. Opponents say it’s unneeded and potentially expensive red tape that would do nothing to aid those with barriers to employment and could potentially hurt those with disabilities or other exemptions.

Gov. Tom Wolf, a Democrat, vetoed a similar bill last year.

Advertise with us

“There is a tension there” around Medicaid, said Judith Solomon, a senior fellow at the left-leaning Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. Since the program’s eligibility greatly expanded under the Affordable Care Act to include more low-income, non-disabled adults, that tension has been brought to a head, she said.

“It’s the way people get health care,” said Ms. Solomon, though she she said some view it as a program that should be more limited.

Antoinette Kraus, director of the Pennsylvania Health Access Network, a nonpartisan group that advocates for access to health care, said she gets frustrated when she hears the w-word applied to Medicaid, a program that provides health coverage for about 2.9 million Pennsylvanians. Many of those are children, disabled or elderly people in nursing homes.

The word invokes a stereotype, she said, of people “abusing the system.” Legislators and others use it because of its pejorative connotation.

“They know it stokes anger in folks,” she said.

Advertise with us

Ann Sanders, public policy advocate at Just Harvest, said, “Somewhere in the ’70s and ’80s — maybe as a reaction to the welfare rights movement that showed that African-Americans asserting their rights to the same services as white people, or maybe it was with the vivid imagery of Reagan's ‘welfare queen’ — ‘welfare’ as a term became a way to leverage this country’s long history of racism as way to attack and punish the poor, rather than support government programs to help them.”

Several years ago, the Pennsylvania department that administers Medicaid and other public assistance programs formally changed its name from the Department of Public Welfare to the Department of Human Services, in part because of the negative connotations of the word “welfare.”

Nathan Benefield, vice president and chief operating officer of the conservative Commonwealth Foundation, which supports work requirements, said the term wasn’t derogatory when programs were initially created decades ago.

“The reason it has become derogatory is, I would say, 60-plus years of mismanaged government programs,” he said.

Mr. Benefield argues that Medicaid could be categorized as welfare.

Advertise with us

“Certainly, when you are talking about providing it for able-bodied adults and providing a means-tested program, I think [that] yeah, it falls under the definition of welfare,” he said.

Steve Miskin, a spokesman for House Republicans, disputed that the word “welfare” had a negative connotation.

“Call it welfare, call it government-subsidized health care, in the end, it is the same thing,” he said.

In an op-ed earlier this month, Ms. Miller, now the state Human Services secretary,noted that the “welfare” label was being broadly applied to Medicaid, in addition to the traditional cash assistance program that most people think of as welfare.

“When most people think of welfare, they probably think of cash assistance or Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF): a monthly check to families in poverty to help them meet their basic needs,” she wrote. “Today, Pennsylvania spends less than .05 percent of state general funds on cash assistance and approximately 1 percent of Pennsylvanians receive this benefit.”

Advertise with us

“The use of the term here is to demonize people who simply fall below a bracket of income and still need, like we all need, access to health care, which is increasingly unaffordable,” Ms. Sanders, the Just Harvest advocate, said.

Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909.