NORRISTOWN — Confronting Bill Cosby's chief accuser Monday, defense lawyer Tom Mesereau teed up the one question he'd been preparing to ask Andrea Constand for months:

"Did you ever tell someone that you could falsely accuse someone else of sexual assault and make a lot of money?"

Prosecutors immediately objected. Montgomery County Common Pleas Judge Steven T. O'Neill called a recess to consider whether Ms. Constand should be required to respond. And in the end, she did.

But by the time she answered with a firm "No," it had been nearly drowned out by the weight of the accusation inherent in the question.

Advertise with us

Such was the dynamic throughout much of Ms. Constand's second day on the witness stand as Mr. Mesereau challenged the only woman whose allegations against Mr. Cosby have managed to put the iconic comedian on trial.

Throughout, the lawyer's questioning seemed designed less to elicit answers from Ms. Constand than to speak directly to jurors.

How well that tactic was able to successfully paint Ms. Constand as a grifter out to make a quick buck by conning a wealthy man will be key to Mr. Mesereau's ability to win an acquittal in the sex-assault case.

Ms. Constand, during her nine hours on the witness stand over two days, largely held firm, sticking to a story she has told now through two trials and been repeating for more than a decade — that Mr. Cosby drugged and assaulted her in 2004 without her consent.

"He touched my breasts," the 45-year-old Canadian massage therapist said. "He placed his fingers inside my vagina. He also placed my hand on his penis."

Advertise with us

Later, the lawyer inquired, "Did you think it was appropriate to be in a married man's hotel room in Connecticut at that time of night?" — a reference to a trip Ms. Constand took to see Mr. Cosby at Foxwoods Casino in Connecticut months before her alleged assault.

When she responded that it was Mr. Cosby who had invited her to his room, Mr. Mesereau quickly moved on, asking similar questions stressing Mr. Cosby's marital status again and again.

He used the same technique while returning to a topic he first broached Friday: emails Ms. Constand had sent to colleagues while working as the women's basketball manager at Temple University to encourage them to pay her $65 to join an online multilevel marketing business. On the stand, Ms. Constand referred to it as "some internet networking thing" she got involved with at the request of a friend.

And although her answer did not change, Mr. Mesereau seemed to delight Monday in posing questions to Ms. Constand that referred to the business as a "pyramid scheme." His repetition of the phrase grew so frequent at one point that Judge O'Neill interrupted him mid-inquiry.

"This is cross-examination as to [her] credibility," the judge said. "What is not relevant is this pyramid scheme."

Advertise with us

During their two-hour back-and-forth Monday, Mr. Mesereau never directly asked Ms. Constand about her alleged assault. Instead, his questions about the purported attack remained focused on inconsistencies in the various statements she gave police about when it had occurred.

When the opportunity arose for Assistant District Attorney Kristen Feden to question Ms. Constand again, she attempted to brush away any damage Mr. Mesereau had done on that point — and took her own opportunity to speak to the jury through her questions.

"Have you consistently maintained what the defendant did to you after he drugged you that night?" the prosecutor asked. "Was there ever a time that you indicated that the crime the defendant committed against you was consensual?"

Ms. Constand responded: "There was not."