You can cross Connoquenessing, East Lackawannock, Lackawaxen, Nescopeck, Nuangola, Orwigsburg, Skippack, Springettsbury and Towamensing off the list of potentially tongue-twisting Pennsylvania casino destinations.

Both East Chillisquaque and West Chillisquaque in Northumberland County are also out of play for new gambling, along with Uwchlan and Upper Uwchlan in Chester County (and no, sorry, there is no Lower Uwchlan to turn to).

Don’t even think about pressing a slot machine button in Lancaster County, where all 60 of its municipalities have shut the door on anyone aiming to set a neon-lit hall among Amish horse-and-buggies.

Additionally, the 11 Union Townships of Adams, Berks, Clearfield, Crawford, Lebanon, Luzerne, Mifflin, Schuylkill, Snyder, Tioga and Union counties nixed the idea of any casino locating within their limits, leaving just six of the state’s 17 Unions — in Centre, Erie, Fulton, Huntingdon, Jefferson and Lawrence counties — ostensibly open to the idea.

Advertise with us

In all, 1,017 of 2,562 Pennsylvania municipalities are listed by the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board as acting by Dec. 31 on an opt-out provision in Pennsylvania’s gambling expansion law. It enabled local officials to say no to hosting one of the state’s 10 potential mini-casinos — also known as satellite, or Category 4, casinos.

On Wednesday, the gaming board will hold a silent auction for the first mini-casino license at its public meeting in Harrisburg. The 11 holders of existing Category 1 and Category 2 licenses may submit an envelope containing a minimum $7.5 million bid for the new license. In a separate envelope they must announce in which municipality they will locate, which can be no closer than 25 linear miles to any competing casino.

Read More

State officials will announce the winner of the high bid and the planned location of the new casino that could have up to 750 slot machines — about one-third to one-fourth the number typical in existing facilities such as the Rivers Casino and Meadows Racetrack & Casino.

Nine more similar auctions are to be held in Harrisburg every few weeks and be completed by May 16. The result will be a smattering of new pins on the state’s casino map representing less desirable gambling locations than those previously chosen, but still deemed worthy of the minimum $7.5 million bid, an additional $2.5 million fee to host up to 30 table games, and tens of millions of dollars in development costs.

No one knows yet how many casinos will bid for the right to develop a satellite operation, or how much they will bid, or where they will want to place their satellite operation. They are all holding their cards as protectively as any poker pro.

Advertise with us

“In any auction process, the potential bidders are going to keep their thoughts close to the vest on how they will undertake this process,” said gaming board spokesman Doug Harbach, who added that one point of emphasis for the state regulators is to make sure no bidding collusion takes place among the casinos.

The primary motive behind the new gambling law was not any interest by the gaming industry in more casinos, but state officials’ thirst for revenue to fill a gap in the 2017-18 state budget. The higher the bids for the 10 potential mini-casinos, the more money comes in. And plenty of choices away from the state’s seemingly casino-saturated Philadelphia and Pittsburgh population centers could be considered worth the investment.

“Even with a significant number of opt-outs, there are still 60 percent of municipalities that have not opted out, and those that have opted out have the opportunity to change their mind if they decide it would be to their benefit,” Mr. Harbach noted.

Many of the 1,000-plus municipalities that opted out are in locations — think rural Forest or Elk County — that would have seemed unlikely for such an investment. The 55 Allegheny County boroughs and townships that opted out are in many cases within 25 miles of both the Meadows and Rivers, so would have been ruled out regardless by the overlapping geographic restriction on new competition.

Even in the case of a northern Allegheny County municipality beyond 25 miles of the Meadows, the Rivers might have little inclination to build a second facility so close to its existing North Shore site. If Cranberry was a consideration as a highway-connected growth area just outside the county, its supervisors nixed that by also opting out.

Advertise with us

There has been speculation that mid-sized cities a decent drive away from existing casinos — such as Reading, York, Altoona or Johnstown — could be considered in the bidding. Lancaster, Gettysburg, Williamsport and State College are among those that removed themselves by opting out, although a smaller community adjacent to such a city could become a site.

“I don’t think it kills all the good opportunities,” Michael Soll, president of The Innovation Group, a gaming consultant, said of the opt-outs. “There’s a handful, at least.”

He speculated that companies will consider populous parts of the state that are under-served by existing gambling opportunities, that have good highway access, that present good marketing opportunities in collaboration with an existing casino or which could represent a smart “defensive” move to keep a competitor from encroaching upon their market.

“There is some gaming [strategy] in it,” Mr. Soll said. “If you’re an operator, you have to not only be able to look at what you might do, but guess at what others might do, and that’s the defensive part.”

Joe Weinert, executive vice president of another consultant, the Spectrum Gaming Group, said the volume of casinos both in and out of Pennsylvania now — compared to when the state enacted its original casino law in 2004 — complicates decision-making for the industry.

Advertise with us

“There are a lot of factors that go into this because building casinos these days is not like it used to be. In the olden days, it was, ‘If you build it, they will come,’ ” Mr. Weinert said. “But with a thousand casinos in 42 states now, including a high density in the Northeastern quadrant of the country, this has to be done carefully.”

Despite those concerns, both analysts expect multiple bids will be submitted Wednesday. They also deemed the western and central parts of the state more likely than the east, as the latter is heavily saturated and more affected by the overlapping 25-mile competitive restriction on new casino placement.

That could make counties such as Westmoreland and Lawrence attractive to a bidder. The latter, in particular, has been rare in actively pursuing a casino, with the Lawrence commissioners last month sending marketing packets inviting interest from all existing casino operators in the state.

Dan Vogler, chairman of the Lawrence commissioners, said only one response came back — an email from a company (he did not want to disclose which one) that said “they would be looking in our region and appreciated us reaching out to them.”

The lack of additional responses was not disappointing, he said, “because when I look at the competitive nature of the industry, I think if these companies are in fact undertaking a search effort, I believe they’re going to be very discreet about it and very low-key. … Our goal was to get our county on their radar screens, and we’re hopeful the effort taken so far has accomplished that.”

Advertise with us

Among those taking the opposite stance, intriguingly, was South Strabane. The Washington County township is located directly on the other side of Racetrack Road from North Strabane, where the Meadows casino is located and generates substantial tax dollars for that municipality.

Chances that the Meadows would want to add a mini-casino across the street from an existing casino would seem remote, but the South Strabane supervisors voted anyway Dec. 28 to become the 14th Washington County municipality to opt out.

“It was not a vote in opposition to gaming,” township manager Brandon Stanick explained afterward. “We did that because we can keep local control over [any potential casino development]. We can always rescind the resolution.”

Just like East Chillisquaque, West Chillisquaque and 1,014 others.

Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.