Pennsylvania's Auditor General is asking the IRS to look into some of the $1 million in bonuses spread among staff and volunteers who helped manage the 2016 Democratic National Convention in Philadelphia.

In a report released Monday, Auditor General Eugene DePasquale said that his six-month review of spending by the convention's host committee didn't find that it had misused any of the $10 million it got from the state.

But "the agreement was too loosely drafted and it would've been almost impossible to not meet the grant requirements," he said at a news conference Monday in Harrisburg. He also chided the state for not including a claw-back provision on the $10 million grant. "The reality is there should be a provision that says if you have enough private money, don't use the state money.”

But he urged the IRS to launch its own review of the controversial bonuses because the host committee was registered as a nonprofit under the federal tax exemption code. Mr. DePasquale said bonuses given to board members Kevin Washo and Eliza Rose, who were also paid staff, might have violated IRS regulations governing nonprofits.

Advertise with us

The report marks yet another blow to the host committee that, by all other accounts put on a successful convention.

The bonuses, which were first reported by the Philadelphia Inquirer and Daily News in May, have stirred criticism from Gov. Tom Wolf, state Republicans and even Democratic powerbrokers such as David L. Cohen. The report also is likely to generate renewed interest by state Republicans, who once called for a hearing in Harrisburg.

Mr. Washo, a Scranton native and onetime executive director of the state Democratic Party, was paid $13,000 monthly as executive director of the nonprofit host committee and received a $310,000 bonus. He also served as treasurer of the board, according to the committee's nonprofit filings. He has previously defended the bonus as appropriate.

Ms. Rose, who previously worked on the campaign of Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa., was paid between $9,000 and $10,000 monthly as the committee's chief operating officer and received a post-tax bonus of $43,238 last year. She served as secretary of the board.

Mr. DePasquale said that the lawyers for the host committee said Mr. Washo and Ms. Rose were paid bonuses as employees, not board members and therefore the payouts were appropriate. But he wants a second look.

Advertise with us

“If they were given payouts as time as employee and not board members, that’s something for the IRS to determine. We felt it was confusing enough for the IRS to review,” Mr. DePasquale said.

He said he did as a courtesy share his report with the Attorney General’s Office but thinks the issue of the bonuses is in the IRS’s wheelhouse. “We thought this was a specific question of 501c6 law and we think it’s IRS.”

“The fact that Mr. Washo’s and Ms. Rose’s names are on the committee’s list of directors appears to present a potential problem with receiving the payouts in late 2016: They are directors, or shareholders, of the nonprofit, and yet IRS regulation states that ‘no part of the net earnings… (may inure) to the benefit of any private shareholder or individual’ of the nonprofit,” his report said.

Their bonuses, along with the bonuses of about a dozen other staffers and several volunteers, ranged from $500 for interns and volunteers to $310,000. The rewards were paid in November, four months after the convention. The amounts were listed in a year-end report filed with the Federal Election Commission on Jan. 31.

The second-highest bonus went to chief financial officer Jason O’Malley, at $220,000. He did not have a board position.

Advertise with us

Former Gov. Ed Rendell served as chairman of the host committee and has consistently defended the bonuses, calling them "deferred compensation" for the time some of the staffers worked without getting paid and for receiving what he called low salaries.

"The Auditor General’s report confirms what we knew all along: that the Host Committee fully complied with the stipulations in the DCED contract and spent those funds completely appropriately and in accordance with legislators’ parameters," he said in a statement released Monday.

The host committee was tasked with fund-raising and organizing the events surrounding the July 25 to 28 Democratic National Convention. The committee raised $86 million, of which $10 million, the largest amount, came from Pennsylvania taxpayers. It wasn't until September, when the committee filed its financial reports with the Federal Election Commission, that it reported exceeding its fund-raising goal.

The committee used its surplus to pay the city more than $500,000 for municipal services incurred during the convention, make $1.2 million in grants to local nonprofits, and provide the bonuses.

On Monday, Mr. DePasquale also chided the state Department of Community and Economic Development Monday for not having a provision in its $10 million grant agreement with the 2016 Host Committee to give any surplus money back to the state.

Advertise with us

The only requirement the grant had was that the money be spent “to pay for infrastructure necessary for the City of Philadelphia to host the Convention including rental and buildout of the Convention arena and other facilities, transportation, communications and technology systems, necessary office space and event security.”

Mr. DePasquale said the $10 million was spent on three major items: $5.8 million went to rental of the Spectrum Arena; $2.5 went to Kirshner Events, which handled production and technology to televise the event; and $1.76 million to Hargrove Inc, the convention’s general contractor. All three were allowed under the grant agreement.

The Auditor General noted that neither the Kirshner nor Hargrove contracts were competitively bid. He suggested that the DCED require all future grants, subgrants and contracts in excess of $10,000 to be competitively bid.

He also suggested that the DCED consider including provision that make sure the state is to be the “payer of last resort,” that any surplus grant funds be returned to the state and that any surplus from privately-raised funds be used to pay back the state for grant funds up to the full amount of the grant.