JOHNSTOWN, Pa. — Criminal charges against an Indiana University of Pennsylvania student accused of killing his fraternity brother have been dismissed.

Indiana County Judge William Martin dismissed both counts, homicide and aggravated assault, saying there was neither physical or eyewitness evidence to suggest Brady DiStefano, 20, of Johnstown, Cambria County, killed the man – let alone that he intended to that night.

In his six-page-order, Judge Martin pointed to the fact a forensic pathologist admitted there was no physical sign Caleb Zweig was strangled to death in February 2017.

And the man who spotted Mr. DiStefano and Mr. Zweig on Wayne Avenue the night of the Rockville, Md., native’s death, indicated the incident he spotted between the two appeared to have started and ended within five or six seconds.

Advertise with us

“To be guilty of criminal homicide by statute, one must have caused the death of another human being,” Judge Martin wrote.

“There is no evidence from the eyewitness that (DiStefano) choked Zweig or that (the witness) was even aware of how Zweig ended up on the ground.”

Mr. DiStefano and Mr. Zweig, 20, were both members of the Phi Delta Theta fraternity at the school when Mr. Zweig died Feb. 3.

Mr. DiStefano was charged in the death days later after prosecutors said he was spotted choking him during an altercation on Wayne Avenue in the borough.

But the Indiana County Coroner’s Office and the pathologist who handled Mr. Zweig’s autopsy said they saw no physical signs whatsoever that the young man was strangled.

Advertise with us

“There wasn’t any muscle bruising – not even redness on his neck,” said defense attorney Tom Dickey, who filed a motion in October asking Martin to dismiss the charges due to a lack of evidence. “It would be like saying someone was shot to death but there being no bullet hole – no entry wound or exit wound.”

But county District Attorney Patrick Dougherty said it’s not necessarily that simple.

He didn’t dispute Mr. Dickey’s recollection of the pathologist’s testimony about a lack of physical evidence, but noted that the investigator also viewed the death as a strangulation regardless. There was no other reasonable explanation for what would have caused a healthy young man to suddenly die, Mr. Dougherty noted.

“No, this isn’t an easy, slam dunk (case),” Mr. Dougherty conceded. “But at this early prima facie stage, we believed we presented sufficient evidence to move this forward.”

Mr. Dickey said his client maintained the two were walking together that night when Mr. Zweig suddenly collapsed to the ground.

Advertise with us

Mr. DiStefano was “devastated” by the loss of his friend and then shocked to learn he was being blamed for it, the Blair County defense attorney said.

“These two were really good friends,” Mr. Dickey said.

It will now be up to Mr. Dougherty’s office to either accept the judge’s ruling or appeal it to Pennsylvania’s Superior Court.

Mr. Dougherty said he’s planning to review Martin’s ruling and will decide which step to take within the next week to 10 days.

Because prosecutors weren’t seeking first-degree murder in the case, Mr. DiStefano has been able to remain out of jail since early this year on $50,000 straight cash bond.