A Pennsylvania appellate court has ruled that a Harrisburg nonprofit that oversees a network of abortion-alternative programs doesn't have to show the state's fiscal watchdog how it spends some of the state money it disburses to the programs.

According to a unanimous Commonwealth Court opinion issued Monday, there is “no dispute” that Real Alternatives uses a particular set of expenses partly for the “development and advancement” of its mission outside the state. The nonprofit sued Auditor General Eugene DePasqale in March after he sought to review that spending, a pot of money approaching $1 million.

Real Alternatives representatives have said the nonprofit’s service providers have agreed to hire it in a second agreement relating to that mission. The Department Human of Services earlier found that Real Alternatives collects a 3 percent fee from the providers by reducing the providers' claim reimbursement, then invoicing the full amount to DHS as direct services. For instance, $97 of a $100 claim would be paid to the provider, with the nonprofit retaining $3.

Judge Renée Cohn Jubelirer wrote in the opinion that there is “no evidence” that “the proposed audit of RA’s documentation relating to the 3 percent fee falls within the authority asserted by [the auditor general]” because that money is “admittedly used to fund expenses that are not permitted” under the grant.

Advertise with us

Now the matter could turn again to the Department of Human Services, which sought to audit the expenses last year and which administers the five-year, $30 million agreement that expired June 30.

“DHS is still reviewing the court’s opinion to determine the next steps given that the court did not enter judgment in either side’s favor, so the case is still pending,” said spokeswoman Kait Gillis. “Moving forward, we are reviewing our options in light of the court’s opinion and the ongoing legal proceedings.”

Both Real Alternatives and the auditor general’s office had a positive outlook about the opinion, though.

“While we don't get to look at 3 percent — and that I'm not happy about, but I respect the court —we also now have it on the record hat they did not spent [some money] according to the grant agreement,” Mr. DePasquale said.

The decision “serves as further evidence that Real Alternatives, as always, conducts our business in a fiscally responsible manner with high accountability,” the nonprofit said in a statement. “It is our hope that this matter now is behind us. ...”

Advertise with us

Real Alternatives has previously explained the payment structure as such: “As is usual in the business world, the two different agreements have offset provisions for payment terms. If I owe you $10 and you owe me $5, it would be awfully silly for me to give you $10 and you then hand me $5 back. It makes much more sense and is more efficient for me to just give you $5.”

The matter is unlikely to end here. DHS also has argued that the 3 percent spending should be subject to review. The agency granted the nonprofit a 90-day contract extension and “takes the opportunity with a new grant agreement to review existing terms to see if something should be revised, and we would do the same thing here.”

Mr. DePasquale expects his audit of the rest of the grant money to be completed soon.

Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1944.