WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump has a much sweeter view of a pending U.S.-Mexico sugar deal than the one held by two Pennsylvania Republicans.

Mr. Trump touted the agreement, announced June 6, in a Twitter post Thursday, calling it “a very good one for both Mexico and the U.S.”

But U.S. Sen. Pat Toomey and U.S. Rep. Charlie Dent, both Republican legislators from Pennsylvania, say the new deal will leave consumers with a bitter taste when they look at their grocery receipts.

The deal addresses complaints from American sugar growers, which have accused Mexico of dumping cheap refined sugar in the U.S. market. It reduces the amount of refined sugar Mexico can export and changes what can be labeled as refined sugar.

Advertise with us

The Trump administration says the deal is an improvement over a 2014 agreement that the U.S. sugar industry says Mexico had continued to circumvent. It also sets a positive tone between the two countries ahead of negotiations over updating the North American Free Trade Agreement, or NAFTA.

But critics say it raises sugar prices paid by consumers and food manufacturers.

Mr. Toomey tweeted back at the president Thursday, linking to a floor speech he gave earlier this month criticizing the agreement as “worse than what it was before” and the continuation of policies that set prices instead of allowing them to be set by the market.

Mr. Toomey said the deal would threaten jobs while favoring large sugar producers “already subsidized by domestic agricultural policies that force American consumers to pay artificially inflated prices for their products.”

Pennsylvania’s 200 confectioners employ nearly 40,000 workers, he said, adding that those companies would be at a disadvantage compared to candy-makers in other countries due to the higher prices.

Advertise with us

The Coalition for Sugar Reform, which represents consumer groups and companies that produce food and beverages, estimates that U.S. consumers will pay an additional $1 billion a year under the deal.

“How does it help ordinary Americans to be forced to pay more for the sugar that we all have to buy? It’s a staple in our food,” Mr, Toomey said, noting that the U.S. is a net importer of sugar, with 35 percent of those imports coming from Mexico. “Well, the answer is, it doesn’t help.”

He had sent a letter to the Commerce Department expressing concerns about the sugar trade discussions. Mr. Dent, an Allentown lawmaker whose 15th District includes several candy-producers, such as Bethlehem’s Just Born, The Hershey Co., and Breinigsville’s Premise Maid, sent a similar letter in May that was signed by most of Pennsylvania’s House delegation.

Mr. Dent tweeted back at the president Thursday to disagree with Mr. Trump’s assessment of the agreement, using the hashtag “#BadDeal.”

“It was a good deal for the sugar cane and the sugar beet growers, but I’ve seen plenty of studies to suggest that for every grower job we protect, we put in jeopardy at least three manufacturing jobs in our country,” Mr. Dent said in an interview.

Advertise with us

Asked about the sugar agreement, Hershey Co. spokesman Jeff Beckman referred to a statement from the Sweetener Users Association that it “will further distort U.S. sugar markets” He added that the company is “aware of the potential for this agreement to increase sugar prices in the long term.”

Mr. Beckman said the majority of sugar used by the company comes from U.S. sources, and that the agreement will not change that approach.

One group, however, was pleased to see the president promoting the deal on social media.

On its homepage, the American Sugar Alliance posted an image of Mr. Trump’s tweet and the words: “Thank you, Mr. President.”

What’s in the sugar deal?

Advertise with us

Mexico agreed to export less refined sugar to the U.S. in response to complaints from U.S. sugar refineries that subsidized Mexican refined sugar undercut their prices.

Mexico can increase exports of raw sugar to U.S. refiners.

The price of raw sugar will rise to 23 cents per pound, up from 22.25 cents, and refined sugar prices will increase to 28 cents per pound, from 26 cents.

If U.S. agriculture officials find that U.S. firms need more imported sugar in any given year, Mexican producers get the first right to fulfill those needs.