Mentally ill inmates still sit for months — sometimes even a year — in jails while waiting for hospital beds, more than 15 months after the state inked a settlement promising improvements, according to a court filing Thursday by the American Civil Liberties Union.
The ACLU today asked U.S. District Judge Sylvia H. Rambo, in the Middle District of Pennsylvania, to consider a preliminary injunction that would force the state to break the logjam that keeps jail inmates from transfer to Torrance State Hospital, in Westmoreland County, and Norristown State Hospital, near Philadelphia. The Pennsylvania Department of Human Services runs the state hospitals.
The state conceded in a January 2016 settlement that it was unconstitutional to park mentally ill inmates in jails for months before they could get treatment to make them competent to stand trial, the ACLU’s attorneys wrote. But since then, the wait times have only gotten worse.
Before transfer to Torrance, the ACLU wrote, mentally ill inmates now wait an average of 106 days — up from 79 days at the time of the settlement. The situation around Norristown was even worse. Last year 15 of the inmates admitted to Norristown had first waited in jail for more than 400 days, the ACLU wrote.
The ACLU’s demands: That the state cut the maximum wait times to seven days, submit to an independent consultant’s analysis of the hospitals’ forensic patients and the inmates awaiting transfer, and that 100 new treatment beds be opened within six months.
The ACLU alleges that when prodded about the problem, the Department of Human Services repeatedly asked for more time to study it, while doing “next to nothing.”
In response to questions, a Department of Human Services spokeswoman wrote that the state has spent $17.6 million on 149 new “community based slots” for people in the forensic mental health system, diverted 340 people from the hospitals’ waiting lists to other settings, converted 60 hospital beds from civil patients to criminal cases, hired an efficiency consultant and launched a data-driven search for solutions.
When defendants are not competent to understand the charges against them or to help their defense lawyers, they must get competency treatment, which the state provides at Torrance in Derry and Norristown in Montgomery County.
In 2015, the ACLU sued on behalf of around a dozen inmates, alleging that many defendants awaiting competency treatment sit in solitary confinement in jails for months on end because of slow turnover at the hospitals. Some inmates have died while awaiting transfer, according to the lawsuit. At the time, there were around 237 forensic beds in the two hospitals.
The settlement called on the state to create 120 new housing slots for patients in the hospitals who could safely live in communities, to free up their beds for the jail inmates. Thursday’s brief says the state has spent money on that effort, but hasn’t solved the underlying problem.
The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette last year chronicled the experiences of a longtime Torrance inmate, investigated a death in the hospital and profiled its new CEO .
Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542. Twitter @richelord






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.