MILFORD, Pa. — It was a moment of humanity that belied the image of a cold-blooded killer that police had crafted for Eric Frein.

Sitting with two state troopers after U.S. Marshals pulled Mr. Frein from a hiding place in the Pocono woods, the man who had allegedly led police on a 48-day manhunt after an ambush on the Blooming Grove barracks wept as he asked about the children of the trooper he is accused of killing.

“You’re both fathers?” Mr. Frein asked the two troopers who were questioning him on Oct. 30, 2014.

“There’s ... a father who didn’t come home,” Mr. Frein continued, wiping his eyes with a tissue.

Advertise with us

Mr. Frein’s lawyers didn’t want jurors to hear his words or see his tears. But on the eve of Mr. Frein’s homicide trial in Pike County, a judge denied the defense’s motion to suppress a video of the interview, rejecting arguments that troopers violated Mr. Frein’s rights by continuing to talk to him after he told them he didn’t want to “answer questions about any crime.”

The denial could halt the trial, which is scheduled to start Tuesday in the county courthouse in Milford, if the defense decides to appeal Judge Gregory Chelak’s ruling. Michael Weinstein, one of Mr. Frein’s two attorneys, said he is mulling an appeal to a higher court.

The defense motion, which was the subject of a daylong pretrial hearing Monday, was based on the defense’s contention that state police Cpl. Benjamin Clark coerced Mr. Frein into answering questions despite a clear declaration from the defendant that he was invoking his right to remain silent.

“Cpl. Clark skillfully ignored the rights of Mr. Frein, and talked to him for several hours during which he incriminated himself dozens of times,” defense attorney William Ruzzo said.

Police have said Mr. Frein was informed of his right to remain silent, but agreed to cooperate. Judge Chelak agreed, ruling the evidence prosecutors want to show the jury was “not obtained in violation of the defendant’s right to remain silent.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Frein also contends that he was denied an attorney in the hours after his arrest. James Swetz, an attorney hired by Mr. Frein’s parents on the night of his capture, testified that police prevented him from speaking to Mr. Frein, even after he showed up at the barracks where Mr. Frein was being questioned and identified himself as Mr. Frein’s attorney.

Mr. Swetz said Mr. Frein’s parents were concerned for his safety after hearing news accounts that Mr. Frein had been arrested without incident, then seeing him on television with facial injuries.

Judge Chelak ruled that Mr. Frein didn’t ask to speak to Mr. Swetz and there’s no evidence that troopers questioning Mr. Frein knew the lawyer was outside the barracks.

District Attorney Raymond Tonkin said the video contains “important evidence” that jurors should see. After the hearing, Mr. Tonkin said he’s ready to start the trial Tuesday.

Mr. Frein is accused of opening fire outside the Poconos barracks on Sept. 12, 2014, killing Cpl. Bryon Dickson II, 38, and critically wounding a second trooper, Alex Douglass.

Advertise with us

Trooper Douglass could be one of the first witnesses at the trial, which will likely focus on forensic evidence. Mr. Frein’s attorneys have not said what direction their defense strategy will take. The trial is expected to last at least five weeks.

Mr. Frein, 33, of Barrett, Monroe County, faces a dozen charges, including first-degree murder of a law enforcement officer, terrorism and possessing weapons of mass destruction. Mr. Tonkin said he will seek the death penalty.

Mr. Frein watched the video intently as it was played in court Monday. It began with Mr. Frein offering to pinpoint on a map where he’d hidden a rifle and assuring the troopers he hadn’t left any explosives in the search area.

Mr. Frein’s demeanor changed when the subject of Cpl. Dickson’s children came up.

Mr. Frein asked how old the kids were and was told they were 5 and 7. He said something that was inaudible on the tape while wiping his eyes.

Advertise with us

“I don’t think you knew he had children,” one officer said, gently. “You didn’t know that beforehand, right?”

On the tape, Mr. Frein appears to shake his head “no” before saying again that he doesn’t want to talk.

“I mean, we’re going to be going at it sometime in court,” he said.