For the first time in a decade, Pennsylvania’s 170 general acute care hospitals in 2015 saw a drop in charity care spending, saving the average hospital about $200,000 over 2014, according to state data obtained by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
Coupled with a nearly $300,000 drop in bad debt at the typical hospital, hospitals saved about $500,000 on uncompensated care in 2015, according to data from the Pennsylvania Health Care Cost Containment Council.
The state hospital association and patient advocates alike believe the drop in spending on charity care and bad debt is due to the impact of the Affordable Care Act, which is what experts said they believed caused a similar drop for the 24 states that adopted the ACA in 2014, as reported in the Post-Gazette series, Counting Charity Care, last year.
Pennsylvania fully adopted the ACA in 2015 by expanding Medicaid to cover nearly 700,000 more people, in addition to helping nearly 500,000 people obtain insurance through the federal Health Insurance Marketplace.
Though about 600,000 more adults remain uninsured, the state’s uninsured rate dropped from 13.8 percent before the ACA, to a historic low of 5.2 percent this past year, according to the Pennsylvania Health Access Network.
The data on charity care and bad debt has both the Hospital and Healthsystem Association of Pennsylvania and patient advocates concerned even more about the future of the ACA, which Presiden president-elect Donald Trump has threatened to — at a minimum — greatly rewrite the law.
“What we’re concerned about, and the value of these numbers show, is the danger of repealing” the ACA, said Antoinette Kraus, director of PHAN, a patient advocacy organization.
The hospital association said, in part, in a statement that the drop in uncompensated care spending and the uninsured rate “are positive indicators that the payment reductions hospitals agreed to in the ACA in order to help fund coverage expansion are benefiting patients and relieving some of the financial strain on hospitals.”
“The Pennsylvania hospital community is hopeful that leaders will proceed cautiously,” the association added.
David Nash, dean of the Thomas Jefferson University’s College of Population Health, said with similar stories playing out across the country it stands that “hospitals will be upset” if Mr. Trump gets rid of the ACA without putting in place something to help decrease costs or increase revenue somewhere else.
“Hospitals now have a larger number of paying customers,” Dr. Nash said, “something most people would see as a good thing.”

PG graphic: Charity care drops
(Click image for larger version)
Kyle Fisher, state attorney for the Pennsylvania Health Law Project, a patient advocacy organization, said it is clear that after dealing with a “patchwork system of insurance where the working poor were largely left out, now we have a largely coherent system where people can finally get insurance. So, no, it’s not surprising to me that hospitals would see an uptick in the number of insured patients.”
One of the hospitals benefiting the most from the drop was UPMC, which saved about $17 million in charity care spending among its 13 hospitals in 2015, dropping its systemwide average per hospital from 2.52 percent of net patient revenue to 2.17 percent. It also saved nearly $3 million in bad debt during that time.
A major reason UPMC’s charity care spending, as a percentage, is so much higher than the state average is that about eight years ago it began using a financial tool known as “presumptive eligibility.” That is a credit-score-like algorithm that lets UPMC qualify people for charity care coverage — rather than classify them as bad debt — without the patient filling out a charity care form.
While hospitals are increasingly using such algorithms, patient advocates don’t like how UPMC and most other hospitals use them because they do not tell the patients qualified this way that they qualified for charity care.
UPMC would not answer questions about the data and said, in part, in a statement that “The PHC4 data does not capture the scope of the nearly $4 billion that UPMC has dedicated to community-focused programs and services over the past five years.”
The use of presumptive eligibility is also seen at Allegheny Health Network, which began using the algorithms in 2014 and also does not tell their patients when they are qualified.
AHN’s charity care spending grew dramatically, rising from $2.8 million in overall charity care spending, or just .18 percent on average at its seven hospitals in 2014, to $19.6 million overall, or 1.18 percent on average at each hospital.
The state’s data also showed that in addition to a real drop in charity care and bad debt spending, the average percentage that hospitals spent on both as a percentage of net patient revenue also dropped.
Charity care spending dropped from an average of 1.19 percent in 2014 to 1.05 percent in 2015.
Pennsylvania’s charity care average was already one of the lowest in the nation in 2014, according to an analysis of federal data in the County Charity Care series.
State experts say while it is good the state’s hospitals are getting more insured patients in their doors, an even lower amount of charity care average adds to the call for hospitals to do more for the remaining uninsured, and the underinsured, with some of those savings.
“One of the things we’re seeing is a shift to higher deductible health plans,” Ms. Kraus said. “There’s a lot of underinsured folks out there. I think we need to start exploring how to help those folks.”
One way, she said, is for hospitals to expand their charity care coverage to cover those larger co-pays and high deductibles that patients are now expected to pay.
Another story that the 2015 data shows is continuing — as shown in the County Charity Care series — is that non-profit hospitals are continuing to shoulder a larger portion of the charitable care burden as the number of for-profit hospitals continue to grow and provide a fraction of the charitable care that non-profits do.
There were five more for-profit hospitals in the state in 2015 compared to 2014, meaning that the 38 for-profits here now make up 22 percent of the state’s 170 general acute care hospitals.
While both for-profit and non-profit hospitals saw drops in the average percentage of charity care they spent, for-profits only provided .34 percent of net patient revenue in charity care in 2015, compared to 1.26 percent for non-profit hospitals.
That included Sharon Regional Hospital, one of only three for-profit hospitals in the western third of the state.
Bought by Community Health Systems in 2014, Sharon told the state it only provided about $43,000 in charity care spending in the last six months of 2014 (because it is switching to calendar year reporting) or just .04 percent of its $102 million in net patient revenue.
That .04 percent was tied for the 20th lowest percentage in the state, and all but one of those lowest 20 averages was a for-profit hospital.
Before CHS’s acquisition in 2014, Sharon routinely provided about $1 million or more in charity care each year, equal to nearly 1 percent of its net patient revenue.
CHS in its purchase documents promised for at least 10 years to “maintain indigent care policies for the hospital with financial terms that are at least favorable to indigent patients as the current charity care polices” prior to purchase.
Despite the dramatic dropoff in charity care spending, which is what has occurred at 14 of 15 other hospitals CHS purchased in Pennsylvania, a Sharon spokeswoman said in a statement: “We believe we are meeting the obligations outlined in the asset purchase agreement.”
Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.