It had looked like another dark legislative year for the two organizations that retrieve organs for transplant in Pennsylvania.

For the sixth year in a row, they failed to persuade the state Legislature to pass a bill they hoped would stop county coroners from denying them access to some organs — something they say has happened 28 times since January 2014.

But just as the legislative session came to an end earlier this week, the bill’s main backers — the Center for Organ Recovery and Education in Pittsburgh and Gift of Life Donor Program in Philadelphia — were heartened to hear that their main antagonist in the battle over the bill, the Pennsylvania State Coroners Association, may be ready to negotiate for the first time.

Pamela Gay, York County’s coroner, said in an interview with the Post-Gazette this week that she was asked by the coroners’ association president, Charles Kiessling Jr., to try to work out language “so we can move forward with this bill.”

Advertise with us

“I’ve been asked to reach out to other coroners and the [organ procurement organizations] to try to reach a solution,” said Ms. Gay, a registered nurse by training who is known to have a good working relationship with Gift of Life.

The change in tone comes after the battle between the coroners association and organ groups had grown increasingly divisive.

The proposed bill, according to its supporters, would put Pennsylvania in line with laws in 47 states and the District of Columbia and includes provisions on education and clinical standards.

But one main goal — the part most upsetting to coroners — is designed to prevent, or at least cut down drastically, on the ability of individual coroners to have their own standards about how and when they can deny access to organs.

Coroners complain that the requirements would complicate death investigations, particularly homicide investigations like in overdose deaths, when it is important to evaluate organs during autopsy, something that makes them non-viable for transplant.

Advertise with us

The bill would have required coroners to give in writing a reason every time they deny access to organs, and coroners could only deny access to organs after they either attend an organ procurement procedure at a hospital or recovery site to get first-hand information, or view it via live video feed.

But the organ groups say on their joint website supporting the bill, savealifenowpa.org, that there are ways to both protect evidence from a body and still recover organs. Twenty-four states and the District of Columbia, for example, have not had one coroner denial since January 2014. Neither has Ms. Gay’s county and other counties in Pennsylvania.

Ken Bacha, Westmoreland County’s longtime coroner who has denied access to organs eight times since 2014 — more than all but one coroner in Pennsylvania (Lehigh County also had eight) — said he is proud that the coroners’ association managed to thwart the organ groups this year again.

“I think it shows our side has caused enough questions and concern with the [state] House legislators that they have caution about this bill,” he said.

Mr. Bacha and many other longtime coroners in the state said they have long histories of bad experiences of working with CORE and Gift of Life that have made them wary of supporting any bill the organ groups support that even sounds like it is trying to take away any of their authority.

Advertise with us

He said there is “absolutely” a lack of trust between him and CORE that is a big part of this dispute for him and other coroners. “And that was created by” CORE.

Mr. Bacha said in one case about eight years ago, CORE representatives told him they would take fluid samples for him while removing organs from a body for donation, but they later told him they “forgot.”

And about five years ago after he denied access to organs in another body, CORE representatives tried to get access to the body anyway, until a driver taking the body to Pittsburgh had second thoughts and called Mr. Bacha’s office.

Susan Stuart, CORE’s president and CEO, said she has heard about Mr. Bacha’s concerns and she does not believe they happened the way he is describing, but he has never detailed them to her.

“Until he makes a statement saying it was about this one particular case, we don’t know how to answer him,” she said.

Advertise with us

Despite the tension that remains between some coroners and the organ groups, Ms. Stuart said she is hopeful that Ms. Gay can find a way to work out an agreeable bill.

“I hope that is a good indication that we might be able to find agreeable language for the next session,” she said.

Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill

That would be a dramatic and sudden change in tone from the coroners association.

In a letter it sent to legislators in September, the association accused organ groups of proposing to teach children that minorities cannot get transplant organs from white people, and that taking prisoners’ organs “could be a good substitute for the death penalty.”

Advertise with us

Those inflammatory accusations, and others, about what the bill and education materials would do, are “demonstrably false,” said Stephen Tornone, assistant general counsel for Gift of Life.

One area that upset the organ groups, and apparently confused legislators when they read it, was when the coroners claimed in the letter that the 28 organ denials by coroners since 2014 “represent 0.0005 % of donations.”

But the organ groups say that percentage figure was a percentage of all death investigations that coroners do, not a percentage of the roughly 900 donation cases made across the state in that time, making the 28 denials represent about 3 percent of all of those cases.

Mr. Kiessling, the longtime Lycoming County coroner - whose name was on that letter along with the association’s general counsel, Susan Shanaman - acknowledged the letter went too far in its accusations.

“That letter was drafted by Susan Shanaman for us, and, when I reviewed it, it hadn’t hit me [that it went too far] but now it does after the fact,” he said in an interview Friday. “But it’s water over the dam; it’s done. We’ve got to move beyond that.”