It’s just after 8:30 a.m. on a recent weekday, and in a room Downtown next to the Allegheny County Assistance Office, the day’s session has begun in Howard Williams’ job search class.
There are motivational slogans written on pieces of paper taped to the gray walls: “We can’t spell success without U.”
“That some achieve great success is proof to all that others can achieve it as well.”
“You’ve got to learn to listen and listen to learn.”
‘Mr. Howard’s class’
Many of Mr. Williams’ students are there because they receive Temporary Assistance for Needy Families — also known as cash assistance, or welfare.
Read More
Far fewer people receive welfare today than 1996, when welfare reform was passed. In Pennsylvania, a little over 531,000 people were receiving welfare in August 1996, when President Bill Clinton signed the reform bill into law. As of June, Pennsylvania had fewer than 158,000 TANF recipients, a decline of more than 70 percent.
Those who do receive the assistance are required to attend classes like this one for at least 20 hours each week.
Back in Mr. Williams’ class, students go around the room and state their names and what kind of job they are looking for — something in the medical field, “something that can help me pay my bills,” a home health aide, a hospitality job.
The class is called EARN. which stands for Employment, Advancement and Retention Network.
The classes are run by EDSI, a for-profit contractor based in Michigan that specializes in job placement for TANF recipients and other economically disadvantaged or unemployed groups.
Recipients are assessed by the county assistance office; those with a previous work history are sent to the EARN program and those without any prior work experience are sent to a different program, said Jonathan Walkush, manager of planning and operations at the Allegheny County Department of Human Services bureau of employment and training.
Despite the drab, bureaucratic setting, Mr. Williams has the gregarious and energetic manner of a game show host or a morning radio DJ and the fervency of a preacher. He punctuates his lecture with silly voices and musical sound effects like a cowbell and the “Jeopardy!” theme song. When one student says he is seeking a job in the food industry, he jokes, “I’m in the eating industry.”
He refers to himself as “Mr. Howard,” as in, “We’re not talking minimum wage in Mr. Howard’s class.”
But underneath Mr. Williams’ jokes and self-deprecation, the former human resources official has lots of good advice for his students — or any job seeker. Be polite. Be punctual. Be prepared. Be positive. Be professional.
As the morning progresses, he reviews how to handle a host of tricky questions — what should you say if a potential employer asks about child care arrangements? What if they ask if you’ve ever filed a workers’ compensation claim? What if they ask if you’ve ever been arrested? How do you talk about how much money you will earn? What can a former employer say about you?
Mr. Williams is a true believer — “It works,” he said. “We really do help people in transition from welfare to work.”
At multiple points during the class, he references the thank-you notes he has received from previous students who have landed well-paying jobs, sitting in a stack on his desk.
“I don’t work for the money,” he said. “I work for those thank-you cards.”
‘They just wanted to help you’
One of the EARN program’s success stories is Jon Magistri.
He had had fast-food jobs previously, but his 2006 felony conviction for receiving stolen property made it hard for the then-single father of two to find a good job.
“I definitely think that having a record like that really hurt me,” he said.
He applied for cash assistance in 2014 and said EARN instructors helped him develop a resume, connected him with employers who were willing to hire someone with a criminal record, and helped him in how to discuss his conviction with potential bosses.
“They told you how to address it, how to talk about it up front, talk about that was your past, stuff like that,” he said.
“They just wanted to help you,” he said.
The 31-year-old North Versailles man has been promoted in his job several times and is now a forklift operator in a warehouse. Last year, at a banquet in Hershey, he was presented with a Governor’s Achievement Award for his success.
“This definitely has helped me get off of cash assistance and food stamps altogether,” he said.
‘A step stool’
One of the EARN students on this day is Kimberly Yonek, 24, of Wilkinsburg. Ms. Yonek has been on cash assistance since November. She, like the other students in her class, has had jobs previously. But, between rent and child care for her 3½-year-old daughter, the telemarketing job she had for a short time previously didn’t leave much left at the end of the month.
She said she feels that she’s learning a lot from this class, which she is mandated to attend for 20 hours every week in order to receive her cash assistance.
For instance, she said, she now knows when calling a prospective employer to check on an application, not to just say she’s checking on her application, but to say, “When would be convenient for me to come in for an interview?” That subtle but meaningful difference has helped her land job interviews she wouldn't have gotten before, she said.
“Mr. Howard’s class is my favorite part about the program,” she said.
Cases like Mr. Magistri’s and Ms. Yonek’s are exactly what many welfare reformers envisioned when they overhauled the cash assistance program 20 years ago: someone who would need the program only for a short time and who would then graduate to full-time employment.
“It’s kind of like a step stool. You don’t want to get comfortable with it, but you want to use it to go somewhere,” Ms. Yonek said, describing her attitude toward receiving TANF, echoing Mr. Clinton’s famous rhetoric that welfare should be a “hand up, not a handout.”
But critics say that states, including Pennsylvania, do a poor job of tracking whether Ms. Yonek and her classmates will actually walk away from the program with better jobs that they will be able to keep long term. State data shows that only about 22 percent of those who leave the TANF program leave because of employment.
A recent report from Community Legal Services of Philadelphia about Pennsylvania’s welfare program criticized the welfare-to-work component of the program as having “little ability to prepare parents for family-sustaining jobs.”
In the past three years, 2,618 people have been enrolled in Allegheny County’s EARN program. Of these, 1,019 have had “successful placements” — meaning they are working 20 hours or more per week and have maintained employment for at least four consecutive weeks, according to county statistics.
“Moving people from welfare to work is a good thing. But right now, we are at 51 percent of the people who leave to get a job come back to us within a year,” said Pennsylvania Human Services Secretary Ted Dallas, reflecting the fact that many are being placed in low-wage service sector jobs that are somewhat economically precarious. He said the department will be offering more performance-based contracts to providers to pay for better outcomes.
“People use the phrase, moving from welfare to work, but we should move them to self- sufficiency,” Mr. Dallas said.
Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909 or on Twitter @KateGiammarise.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.