A couple years since alumni elected him to the Penn State University board, people ask former state Sen. Bob Jubelirer two things when he’s out and about.

They often want to know when the school will restore the bronze statue of Joe Paterno, the late football coach, that stood outside Beaver Stadium.

But the other common question centers on three less-famous names: Graham Spanier, Tim Curley and Gary Schultz, the three former Penn State administrators charged with failing to alert authorities to child predator Jerry Sandusky. Nearly five years since Sandusky’s arrest in November 2011, Mr. Jubelirer said, Pennsylvanians are itching to know whether the onetime executives will face a trial at all.

“It’s time, I think, for either a trial that is fair — or throw it out,” said Mr. Jubelirer, 79, of State College, who was the Senate president pro tempore for 21 years. He considers the former administrators “decent, honest people” who “would not tolerate anything resembling or happening with sexual abuse by a member of the Penn State family,” he said.

Advertise with us

Although the state Superior Court in January quashed several of the most serious counts against the men, they’re still charged with failure to report suspected abuse and endangering the welfare of children. Whether they head to trial could hinge on defense motions filed this month, asserting that the statute of limitations should invalidate the remaining counts and that the men were not state-mandated reporters, among other arguments.

Attorney General Kathleen Kane’s office has until Aug. 19 to file a response, and her spokesman Jeffrey A. Johnson said in a statement that the office looks “forward to presenting this case to a jury." Neither he nor defense attorneys speculated about a trial date. Retired Berks County Judge John Boccabella, who is presiding over the case in Dauphin County, did not return a phone call.

All three defendants have maintained their innocence.

“The Office of Attorney General has always, and continues, to put the protection of children in the forefront of our work,” Mr. Johnson said, declining to detail the prosecution’s plans. In the past, prosecutors have alleged the former administrators sat on crucial information about Sandusky after a 2001 shower incident on the University Park campus.

Their failure to speak up allowed the retired assistant football coach to abuse at least four more boys before his arrest, according to the state’s previous arguments. A Centre County jury in June 2012 convicted Sandusky, 72, of abusing or endangering 10 boys over 15 years. He is appealing while he serves a 30- to 60-year sentence at the State Correctional Institution Greene, near Waynesburg.

Advertise with us

At the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, executive director David Clohessy said the cases against Mr. Spanier, Mr. Curley and Mr. Schultz have sent a message, even if they aren’t convicted. Mr. Spanier was Penn State president for about 16 years, while Mr. Curley served as athletic director and Mr. Schultz as a vice president.

“I think the charges alone have already had a positive impact by forcing people to think: ‘Wow — the next time there’s a hint of possible child [abuse], I’ll risk losing my job instead of being put on trial like those guys were,’” Mr. Clohessy said.

He called prosecution of abuse enablers “stunningly infrequent” but a powerful deterrent against “callousness by employers and colleagues of child molesters.” He said that it’s “pretty far-fetched” to think that university leaders never had an inkling that Sandusky was dangerous, he said.

“Charges like these, however uphill the battles like these might be for law enforcement, really can make sure the child molesters are caught after victim No. 2 instead of victim 32,” Mr. Clohessy said.

Still, former Pennsylvania Attorney General Walter W. Cohen said the legal case against the former administrators remains flimsy and “shouldn’t have gone anywhere” in the first place.

Advertise with us

“They had no obligation to report, legally,” Mr. Cohen said.

He said only medical personnel and people who were in a direct supervisory role over children had a legal duty to report suspected child abuse in the early 2000s. Lawmakers expanded the state standard in 2007 to reclassify people in the administrative roles as mandatory reporters, Mr. Cohen said.

He criticized arguments that the administrators had a legal duty to report past observations under the revised law.

“I’m not excusing what happened. I’m just saying it was not criminal at that [earlier] time, and it can’t be made criminal because you don’t like it,” Mr. Cohen said.

Meanwhile, an attorney for Mr. Spanier, Timothy K. Lewis, said the former president “remains confident, as he has been all along, that he will be fully vindicated.” Mr. Spanier was charged in November 2012.

Advertise with us

Initial charges arrived a year earlier for Mr. Schultz and Mr. Curley, whose attorney, Caroline M. Roberto, said in a statement that she had yet to meet with Judge Boccabella. He took over the case late last month after Dauphin County judges recused themselves.

Thomas J. Farrell, who represents Mr. Schultz, declined to comment for publication. But Bruce Antkowiak, a Saint Vincent College law professor, said a plea deal “is always a possibility.”

“No matter where you try this case in Pennsylvania, it doesn’t matter: It’s going to be very hard to get people who would be able to say, ‘Yes, I think I can be a fair person on this case,’” said Mr. Antkowiak, citing widespread publicity. “Where would you go for a jury in Pennsylvania that was not saturated with information regarding this case?”

Another wrinkle: Mr. Antkowiak said evidence that hasn’t appeared yet in public documents could arise at a trial. Thomas Kline, a Philadelphia attorney who represented a Sandusky victim, agreed.

He said testimony at a trial would examine who at Penn State had information about Sandusky. Men claiming abuse by Sandusky have said that some university athletics employees including Mr. Paterno saw or heard about alleged misconduct as early as the 1970s and 1980s, according to sworn testimony in a separate civil lawsuit.

Advertise with us

The Paterno family and former Penn State workers have disputed or denied those allegations. Mr. Jubelirer, the Penn State board member, said it isn’t clear whether a criminal trial for the former administrators would bring closure.

But “I’m doggone invested in getting to the truth of what the heck happened here,” he said.

Adam Smeltz: asmeltz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2625 or on Twitter @asmeltz.