A Harrisburg nonprofit that has a $30 million, five-year state contract and oversees a network of centers that counsel women to seek alternatives to abortion has set aside $500,000 of its public funding for certain expenses — including some to support similar programs in other states, according to a recent audit.
But the nonprofit agency, Real Alternatives, refused to let the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services, which conducted the audit covering July 2012 through June 2015, review those expenses.
DHS administers the Real Alternatives grant using $1 million in federal assistance program money and about $5 million from the state’s general fund yearly. Those dollars go to 29 nonprofit service providers that operate 93 sites, which Real Alternatives monitors. Providers must pledge not to discriminate or charge fees for their services and must also “maintain a pro-life mission,” according to the contract, which expires in 2017.
Auditors found that Real Alternatives collects a 3 percent fee from service providers by reducing the providers’ claim reimbursements. (For instance, $97 of a $100 claim would be paid to the provider, with Real Alternatives retaining $3.) The nonprofit then invoices the full amount to DHS as direct services, according to the audit.
The audit report said that $497,468 has been collected from the 3 percent fee since July 1, 2012, but noted that “only a portion of the amount collected has been expended.”
The money appears to have been earmarked at least in part for similar programs outside of Pennsylvania. Real Alternatives’ website claims it has helped 14 other states start “taxpayer-funded programs to reach out to women facing unexpected pregnancies.”
“RA management stated that the fee is used to fund expenses that are not permitted under the grant agreement, such as travel and other expenses to support advancement of the program in other states,” the audit states.
Real Alternatives management told DHS the fee is voluntary and formalized in separate agreements with the service providers “for the development and advancement of its programs and mission.” It maintained in its written response to the review that DHS lacks the authority to audit those “private” contracts.
“Over the past 20 years, DHS and Commonwealth auditors understood that due to the fee-for-service legal relationship between Real Alternatives and its vendor service providers, once funds are earned by service providers, it is their money to use ... and is no longer the Commonwealth’s money,” Real Alternatives said in its response to the audit.
Under its contract with the Department of Human Services, Real Alternatives receives about $604,000 annually for administrative costs, which supports five full-time and five part-time employees.
Real Alternatives did not answer a reporter’s questions related to where personnel had traveled and for what purposes. The scope of the organization’s role in other states is unclear.
But in response to emailed questions, the organization emphasized that Pennsylvanians are not subsidizing other states’ programs.
“The service providers who have earned money by providing service to women in need have voluntarily agreed to help Real Alternatives scrupulously comply with the [DHS] agreement and advance the work of Real Alternatives [throughout] the nation. The service providers gladly subsidize this life-affirming work.”
DHS recommended its Office of Social Programs determine whether the 3 percent fee is appropriate; if so, it should specify potential uses of the fee, and if not, it should recover the funds or require Real Alternatives to reimburse service providers, according to the audit.
The review of the nonprofit’s finances found that Real Alternatives was otherwise generally in compliance with the grant requirements. But auditors did note “internal control weaknesses” and recommended better documentation and on-site monitoring of all providers. DHS also found nearly $485,000 in inappropriate billings, mostly from one organization, located in Braddock, and recommended its Office of Social Programs recover the money.
Real Alternatives brought the billing irregularities by that organization, Pittsburgh Family Development, to DHS’ attention, prompting the audit. A number listed for Pittsburgh Family Development was not working this week. Real Alternatives in its response agreed the money should be recovered but disputed the estimated amount.
DHS Secretary Ted Dallas would not discuss details of the audit this week but said the department is reviewing the findings and “determining the most appropriate next steps.”
“The most important thing is to make sure we’re providing quality services according to the requirements of the grant and that those services are being delivered,” he said.
Pennsylvania Auditor General Eugene DePasquale on Monday said his office plans to begin a review of DHS’ oversight of Real Alternatives in June or July.
“I’m going to keep an open mind on all of this,” he said, noting the 3 percent fee matter “is one of the items we’ll be reviewing in very close detail.”
Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1944 or on Twitter @molly_born.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.