PHILADELPHIA — Andrea Constand’s lawyer on Friday accused Bruce L. Castor Jr. of lying when the former Montgomery County district attorney raised questions about her client’s credibility during a February hearing in Bill Cosby’s sex assault case.

Mr. Castor’s testimony was untruthful, lawyer Bebe Kivitz said, and was meant to undermine Ms. Constand as the key witness in Mr. Cosby’s criminal case if it proceeds to trial.

“He was on a crusade,” Ms. Kivitz said, urging a federal judge in Philadelphia to grant her access to communications Mr. Cosby’s lawyers had with Mr. Castor before he took the stand.

Her statements came during a brief hearing in a separate case — a suit Ms. Constand filed last year in which she accused the former prosecutor of slandering her in media interviews explaining his decision a decade ago not to charge Mr. Cosby with drugging and assaulting her.

Advertise with us

U.S. District Judge Eduardo Robreno agreed that Mr. Castor’s February testimony could have relevance to Ms. Constand’s defamation claims and ordered Mr. Cosby’s criminal defense lawyer, Brian McMonagle, to disclose all contact he had with Mr. Castor.

“You’re not entitled to what he’s [Mr. McMonagle] doing in the criminal case,” he told Ms. Kivitz. “You’re entitled to his communications with Castor, a third party.”

The judge also approved agreements Mr. Castor, Mr. Cosby and the Montgomery County District Attorney’s office had reached prior to the hearing about Mr. Castor’s access to the original police statements from his 2005 investigation, records he has said he needs to defend himself against Ms. Constand’s lawsuit.

Mr. Castor’s lawyers, Robert Pugh and Justin A. Bayer, attended the proceeding but did not address Ms. Kivitz’s claims about their client’s February testimony. In a statement after the hearing, Mr. Pugh said: “Mr. Castor did not object because Mr. Castor has absolutely nothing to hide.”

Since county prosecutors charged Mr. Cosby in December, Mr. Castor has emerged as a central figure in the 78-year-old entertainer’s defense.

Advertise with us

Mr. Cosby’s lawyers say that the criminal case should be thrown out, citing a promise the former district attorney made in 2005 that their client would never be prosecuted for the alleged assault of Ms. Constand.

Mr. Castor backed up their story on the witness stand in February and continues to be frequently cited in the Cosby team’s legal briefs as the Pennsylvania Superior Court weighs whether to overturn a lower courts decision to allow the sex assault case to proceed.

In his testimony, Mr. Castor said that he had been troubled by inconsistencies in Ms. Constand’s 2005 statements to police and by the fact that she had contacted a civil lawyer before reporting the alleged assault to authorities.

“She had ruined her own credibility and would not be believed by a jury,” he said. “That did not mean she was not telling the truth.”

Ms. Kivitz argued Friday that such testimony amounted to Mr. Castor “continuing the defamation” at the core of her client’s civil suit against him. “Whatever documents Mr. McMonagle gave to Mr. Castor are very relevant to our case,” she said.