HARRISBURG — The state’s judicial ethics court cast a critical eye Thursday on its own investigative agency, seeking more information about what some have called a botched inquiry into offensive emails exchanged by Supreme Court Justice J. Michael Eakin.

At a hearing for the justice, a three-judge panel demanded that the Judicial Conduct Board, which investigates ethics complaints against judges, answer a list of questions about its initial investigation of Justice Eakin.

That inquiry, in late 2014, concluded that Justice Eakin had not violated any ethics rules when he sent or received emails that contained nudity, mocked minorities and illegal immigrants, and made demeaning jokes about women and others.

The conduct board reopened the investigation last fall, after state Attorney General Kathleen Kane raised questions about whether the justice had been given a pass.

Advertise with us

Last month, it charged Justice Eakin with engaging in conduct “so extreme that it brought the judicial office into disrepute.” He could face a trial as early as spring.

The panel of the Court of Judicial Discipline said Thursday that it wanted the detailed information from the board by next month. The disciplinary court’s request was an unusual twist to Thursday’s hearing, which focused on who might testify at Justice Eakin’s trial.

His lawyer raised the possibility of calling other Supreme Court justices and forcing them to testify about questionable emails they received, but he said he would do that only if the panel insisted on scrutinizing emails Justice Eakin received as well as those he sent.

As for the inquiry into the previous investigation, the panel demanded to know whether Justice Eakin or the Judicial Conduct Board’s chief counsel, Robert A. Graci, disclosed their political and social ties. Mr. Graci, who oversaw the probe, was a lawyer for Justice Eakin’s 2011 retention campaign and is a longtime friend of the justice.

Ms. Kane said her office found and offered to Mr. Graci new and damaging Eakin emails days after the conduct board had cleared him of wrongdoing, but that Mr. Graci ignored them.

Advertise with us

In the misconduct proceedings against the justice, the disciplinary court is seeking all statements he made to the Judicial Conduct Board, has asked whether those statements were made under oath, and has asked what emails the board had in its possession when it cleared Justice Eakin the first time around.

The board assigned a new staffer to lead the second review. In its detailed complaint against Justice Eakin, the board glossed over Ms. Kane’s complaint that it had previously ignored emails.

Ms. Kane’s critics have said her decision to publicly release Justice Eakin’s emails was driven by revenge. Justice Eakin joined his colleagues in September in temporarily suspending the attorney general’s law license after she was charged with perjury and other offenses.

One of Eakin’s attorneys, William Costopoulos, asked the panel to make a distinction between emails Justice Eakin sent and those he received.

The majority of the 120 emails cited in the conduct board’s complaint against Justice Eakin were ones he received. Mr. Costopoulos said Justice Eakin sent 18 messages, all from a private account, to a small group of friends that included a lawyer in Ms. Kane’s office.