As 2016 begins, a group of Pennsylvania legislators is making a resolution to overhaul the state’s lobbying laws. But some insiders say a few proposals indulge in an old Harrisburg habit: political payback.

As proposed by five Senate Republicans, including Allegheny County’s recently elected Guy Reschenthaler, the “Lobbyist Reform Package” includes six measures, among them: stricter reporting of gifts to state officials, increasing fines on lobbyists who violate such requirements, and requiring state officials to disclose when a spouse or other family member is a lobbyist. Another proposal would prohibit lobbyists from being paid to work on political campaigns or having financial ties to a consultant who does.

“Lobbyists have their place … but the influence they wield continues to grow exponentially,” Sen. Scott Wagner, R-York, said in a statement last month. He blamed their “overwhelming outside influence” for hindering budget talks and initiatives such as privatizing the state’s liquor stores.

Mr. Wagner’s chief of staff, Jason High, said he hoped for hearings on the package this month. Supporters say changes are overdue.

Advertise with us

The current law “hasn’t had the effect we hoped for on conflicts of interest or other things you don’t see in the ‘I’m Just a Bill’ video,” said Nathan Benefield of the conservative advocacy group Commonwealth Foundation.

Even some lobbyists say an overhaul is needed.

“I think it’s time for a change,” said Roy Wells, who heads the lobbying firm Triad Strategies. “I’m for whatever level of transparency they want to legislate.”

But several insiders say elements of the package appear to be targeted at one firm, Long Nyquist and Associates, and two of its clients: United Food and Commercial Workers Local 1776, which represents state store workers, and the Pennsylvania State Education Association, which represents schoolteachers across the state.

“To me, this is just a schoolyard bully trying to push around the other kids,” said Wendell Young IV, president of Local 1776.

Advertise with us

Long Nyquist has particularly close ties to Republican leaders in the Senate, whose cautious approach to liquor reform has sometimes frustrated conservatives. The firm’s two named partners, Michael Long and Todd Nyquist, previously worked for Joseph Scarnati, the Senate president pro tempore. Its vice president of government relations, Megan Crompton, is married to Drew Crompton, general counsel for the Senate Republicans.

Mr. Wagner, meanwhile, has a different connection to the firm: Long Nyquist worked on behalf of his Republican opponent in a bruising 2014 election campaign. In a Harrisburg TV news report that year, Mr. Wagner called the firm a “cancer.”

Mr. High said “it is more than Long Nyquist that [the reforms] would impact.” But although it is difficult to gauge how many lobbyists are paid for campaign work, Long Nyquist is widely considered a pioneer of the practice.

Drew Crompton said it was easy to overstate the power of such ties.

“We’ve opposed the PSEA stridently on a lot of things,” he said.

Advertise with us

“There’s merit in some of the bills: Disclosure is good, generally,” Mr. Crompton continued.

“I don’t fear disclosure,” he said about his spouse’s role, “what I fear is putting up scarlet letters people don’t deserve. I’m very sensitive to the ethics of my job. But that won’t dissuade people from suggesting there is something bad going on, and that’s offensive to me.”

State Sen. Camera Bartolotta, the Monongahela Republican sponsoring the spousal disclosure measure, said that although she wanted to ensure “that everyone knows who is connected where,” it was not aimed at any particular individual.

“I have a staffer who is married to a lobbyist. It has never caused a problem,” she said.

Mr. Long declined to comment for this story, except to call the some of the changes “blatant attempts to cancel the rights outlined by our founders, including the right to petition the government.”

Advertise with us

Ken Paulson, president of the national First Amendment Center, said he is “not certain there’s a First Amendment issue here” but that prohibiting lobbyists from doing campaign work was unusual.

“Most of the [lobbying] legislation we see relies entirely on disclosure. The closer you get to limiting someone’s right to participate in the political process, the thinner the ice is,” he said.

Barry Kauffman, who heads the political watchdog group Common Cause Pennsylvania, countered, “If you’re a lobbyist that runs a political consulting firm serving legislators, your clients might have a huge advantage.” As for whether the changes were motivated by score-settling, he said, the proposals are “moving the ball forward, so I’m not going to ascribe motives.”

Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com or 717-787-4254. Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.