HARRISBURG — Call it a case of strange bedfellows, courtesy of Pennsylvania’s prolonged budget stalemate.
A recent House vote on a proposed overhaul of the state’s pension systems for state and public school employees had groups that usually oppose each other — public sector unions and conservative organizations that favor less government spending — working on the same side, but for opposite reasons.
With the pension bill under attack from both the left and the right, it went down in flames in a 149-52 vote, with all Democrats and more than half of the Republicans in the House opposing the bill. The proposal would have created a “side-by-side” hybrid plan with new state and school employees in both a reduced version of the current defined benefit plan, with an additional 401(k)-style component. Current employees — including legislators — could remain in their current pension plan or join the new one.
The bill’s defeat threw into question an entire framework for ending the state’s nearly six-month budget impasse. The framework had included the pension reforms sought by Senate Republicans as well as a budget that would have the higher education funding sought by Democratic Governor Tom Wolf.
In the wake of the pension bill’s defeat Saturday, each side has pointed the finger at the other. Republicans have accused Democrats of abandoning their governor, and Democrats have said Republicans were not able to pass a bill that for years has been a stated Republican priority.
Drew Crompton, the top lawyer for Senate Republicans, said there’s enough blame for both sides.
“I think [Democratic Appropriations Chairman Joe] Markosek saying it’s not part of the framework is laughable. And I think it was certainly disappointing to see that many Republicans walk away from a priority of theirs and a priority of ours, and a bill that got endorsed by [The] Pew [Charitable Trusts] and ALEC [the American Legislative Exchange Council] and every organization in between,” Mr. Crompton said Sunday.
ALEC describes itself as an organization of state legislators who support limited government and free markets.
“It was disappointing for a lot of reasons,” Mr. Crompton said.
The bill passed the Senate in a bipartisan vote.
House Democrats opposed the bill because it would have hurt retirement security for future workers, said Bill Patton a spokesman for House Democrats. He said Democrats had never committed to voting for that part of the framework, and pointed out that a previous attempt at a pension overhaul that passed the House and Senate in June passed the House with entirely Republican support — only 11 Republicans opposed it. That bill was later vetoed by Mr. Wolf.
David Broderic, a spokesman for the Pennsylvania State Education Association, said his union’s members advocated “against a bill that was bad for taxpayers, bad for educators, bad for Pennsylvanians.”
“We opposed this bill from day one,” Mr. Broderic said.
Conservative opponents of the bill who normally support pension reform saw it as a proxy for the budget Mr. Wolf has advocated for, because the bill became tied to the budget framework.
“If a defeat of the pension bill meant a defeat of the tax increases, that would be a worthwhile sacrifice,” said Matthew Brouillette, president and CEO of the conservative Commonwealth Foundation, a group that has long advocated for changes to public sector pensions. “This was our basic calculation.”
Mr. Brouillette said while his organization in this instance was on the same side of an issue as several public sector unions, he stressed the two were in no way working together.
“We absolutely were not working with them. We needed to keep them in the dark about this,” he said.
Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com, 717-787-4254 or on Twitter @KateGiammarise.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.