HARRISBURG — A Commonwealth Court judge has denied an injunction to a coalition of foster family agencies and group home service providers that had sued the state, hoping to compel the Department of Human Services to release funds during the ongoing budget impasse.
The budget stalemate, which is now in its sixth month, has halted millions in aid to social services.
The Pennsylvania Council of Children, Youth and Family Services sued Gov. Tom Wolf and the Department of Human Services in Commonwealth Court in September, arguing their services should be deemed “essential,” and thus funded during the budget impasse.
Commonwealth Court Judge Robert Simpson wrote, “While in a common sense, non-legal context, a strong argument can be made that child welfare services, especially those that are court-ordered, should qualify as ‘essential services’ deserving of continued funding, the current controversy also implicates important state constitution and separation of powers issues. ... [W]e reluctantly deny PCCYFS’s” application for an injunction, he wrote in an opinion last month.
The ruling also stated these funds are ultimately “subject to the appropriations process and require an approved appropriations act,” referring to a budget.
During the impasse, payments are still being made for state payroll, federal entitlement programs such as Medicaid, payments for the “health and safety of those” in the commonwealth’s custody such as prisons and state hospitals, public safety programs such as the state police, and programs not subject to the appropriations process, such as unemployment compensation or debt service payments.
Read More
“While this Court would welcome a change in current law to make PCCYFS’s right to relief clear, law change authority is not within our current portfolio,” Judge Simpson wrote.
A spokesman for Mr. Wolf declined to comment.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.