HARRISBURG — Democratic candidate Alice Beck Dubow continued a family tradition on Tuesday, winning a seat on the Superior Court where her mother once served.
Judge Dubow, 56, who sits on the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia, defeated the Republican candidate, Judge Emil Giordano of the Court of Common Pleas of Northampton County, in the race for the court's lone open seat.
"Personally, this is a huge landmark for me and my family, and also for women in Pennsylvania," Judge Dubow said Tuesday night. "My mother was the first woman ever elected to Superior Court, in 1983. It's just wonderful that 30 years later the next generation of Beck women is going to serve on Superior Court."
She said her mother, Phyllis Beck, had been standing beside her watching the results come in.
Judge Dubow thanked Judge Giordano for running a campaign "that was about the differences in our judicial philosophy."
And he congratulated her on her campaign.
Read More
"I wish her well," Judge Giordano said. "I know she'll do a great job."
The Superior Court, one of two statewide intermediate appellate courts, is responsible for appeals in criminal and most civil cases from the Court of Common Pleas. The Superior Court also hears appeals in matters involving children and families.
The two candidates described themselves during the campaign as having different judicial philosophies.
Judge Giordano described himself as a “strict constructionist” who believes the power to change the law belongs only to the Legislature. Judge Dubow, by contrast, said that while she respects the limits imposed by the General Assembly, she believes the courts have a responsibility to ensure the law reflects changes in society.
The candidates also presented a contrast on the issue of the death penalty. Judge Giordano said he believes the moratorium declared by Gov. Tom Wolf, a Democrat, has no effect. Judge Dubow said she does not know the answer to the question about Mr. Wolf’s action, which is being considered by the state Supreme Court after a challenge by the Philadelphia district attorney.
Judge Dubow was elected to the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia in 2007. Before that, she worked as a law clerk, an attorney in private practice, an assistant city solicitor for Philadelphia and deputy general counsel for Drexel University. She has said the most memorable, and probably the most difficult, cases she has handled as a judge are those involving abused and neglected children.
Before his election to the Court of Common Pleas of Northampton County in 2003, Judge Giordano worked as an assistant district attorney, an assistant public defender and lead counsel for his own law practice.
Karen Langley: klangley@post-gazette.com, 717-787-2141 or on Twitter @karen_langley.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.