Briefs were filed in state Supreme Court late last week in the appeal of a class-action lawsuit involving funding for the Luzerne County public defender’s office in a case that could resonate across Pennsylvania.
The question pending before the state’s highest court is whether three indigent criminal defendants and a former chief public defender have standing to bring the lawsuit alleging a violation of the Sixth Amendment right to counsel, and whether their claims have merit.
“Poor people, much less poor people charged with crimes, don’t have the clout to convince county leaders to adequately fund public defender offices, thus making access to courts to fix systemic constitutional violations vitally important,” said Witold Walczak, legal director for the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania.
In April 2012, Mr. Walczak and several other attorneys filed a class-action lawsuit in state court on behalf of Luzerne County’s chief public defender, Al Flora Jr., and three indigent defendants, claiming that the office of the public defender could not adequately represent its clients with the level of funding that it received.
Among the claims: that the attorneys carried caseloads in excess of those recommended by the American Bar Association; that there was insufficient support staff, desks and phone lines; that defendants were incarcerated for longer periods because public defenders were forced to continue preliminary hearings because of a lack of preparation, and that the attorneys, generally, did not have adequate time and resources to properly represent their clients.
Under the lawsuit, the plaintiffs sought an injunction forcing the county to increase funding to the office to hire additional attorneys and support staff, and to upgrade its office technology.
Although the county judge on the case, Joseph M. Augello, granted a temporary injunction requiring that a handful of vacancies in the office be filled, the case was dismissed by the same judge in October 2013.
He found that Mr. Flora had no standing to bring the complaint, because he’d been fired by the county — for which a federal retaliation lawsuit is now pending — and neither did the individual defendants, because it had not been proved that they had been subjected to ineffective assistance of counsel.
The plaintiffs appealed to the Commonwealth Court, and in October 2014, a three-judge panel of Bonnie Brigance Leadbetter, Robert “Robin” Simpson and Mary Hannah Leavitt ruled in favor of Luzerne County.
“We conclude that Flora lacks traditional standing because he is not personally aggrieved by the county’s alleged failure to fund the office of public defender adequately. He is not directly impacted by the county’s actions any more than other individual citizens. As a result, his interest is not substantial, direct, or immediate,” the Commonwealth Court wrote.
In its 23-page opinion, the panel also found that whether the indigent defendants are provided effective assistance of counsel will be addressed in their criminal cases.
“The amended complaint does not allege facts to support the inference that the indigent clients have or will suffer irreparable harm, but only the fear that they will not be adequately represented.”
Funding should not be addressed through the courts, the appellate panel found.
“The funding at any office of public defender presents a series of political and public policy challenges, as do all programs established to serve society’s less fortunate,” wrote Judge Leavitt. “These questions are better resolved in the political process, which includes the county’s budgetary processes.”
The state Supreme Court agreed to take the case, and the appellants’ briefs — along with four friend-of-the-court briefs from the American Bar Association, the Innocence Project, the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers and the Department of Justice — were filed last week.
In its brief, DOJ attorneys wrote that the United States has a strong interest in ensuring that all jurisdictions are “fulfilling their constitutional obligation to provide counsel to criminal defendants facing incarceration who cannot afford an attorney,” and in 2010 launched the Office for Access to Justice to address the crisis in indigent defense services.
“The Commonwealth Court’s opinion in this case is the only decision the United States is aware of that concludes that a Gideon-based civil action for constructive denial of counsel is not viable at all. It erects a roadblock that will impede indigent defendants’ ability to vindicate their Sixth Amendment right to counsel.”
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.