PHILADELPHIA — The state Supreme Court heard arguments Thursday in a challenge by the Philadelphia district attorney to Gov. Tom Wolf’s declaration that he would impose a moratorium on the death penalty in Pennsylvania.
In February, shortly after taking office, Mr. Wolf said that until the pending recommendations of a Senate task force and advisory committee were received and addressed, he would grant a reprieve in each case in which an execution was scheduled. In explaining his decision, he cited questions about the “fundamental fairness” of capital sentencing in Pennsylvania, such as indications that people are more likely to be charged with a capital offense and sentenced to death if they are poor or members of a racial minority.
The associations of Pennsylvania district attorneys and state troopers criticized the move, as did Republican legislative leaders.
The Philadelphia district attorney, Seth Williams, filed a challenge to the moratorium in the case of Terrance Williams, who received the first reprieve under Mr. Wolf’s policy. Terrance Williams was convicted of murdering a man in 1984. According to the district attorney’s filing, he beat the man with a tire iron and then left his body lying between tombstones in a cemetery.
In court Thursday, Hugh Burns, chief of the appeals unit in the district attorney’s office, said that while the governor is permitted to issue a reprieve from execution, he is not allowed to put a permanent stop to the death penalty. He noted that a governor can issue a permanent halt to a person’s execution only after a unanimous recommendation by the state Board of Pardons.
“This was an open-ended reprieve that has the effect of a commutation,” Mr. Burns said.
Read More
Geoff Moulton, deputy general counsel for Mr. Wolf, told the justices that the governor is empowered to issue reprieves at his discretion. He said Wolf’s halting of the executions in question is not permanent, even though there is no stated endpoint. “These reprieves are both temporary and indefinite,” he said.
Pennsylvania last executed a prisoner in 1999 and most recently put to death someone contesting his sentence in 1962.
As of Sept. 1, the state had 180 men and two women sentenced to be executed, according to the Department of Corrections.
The task force and advisory committee Mr. Wolf cited in his announcement of a moratorium was created in 2011 by the Senate, which set a due date for its report in December 2013. But the report has yet to be delivered. The office of Sen. Stewart Greenleaf, who sponsored the resolution creating the committee, has been told the report would not be completed until at least early 2016, said spokesman Aaron Zappia. He said it is taking time to collect records from the state’s courthouses.
In addition to the reprieve for Terrance Williams, Mr. Wolf has issued a reprieve for Hubert Michael, who was convicted of murdering a teenage girl in York County in 1993, and for Robert Diamond, who was convicted of shooting two men to death in Bucks County in 2008.
Karen Langley: klangley@post-gazette.com or 1-717-787-2141.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.