HARRISBURG –– For many Pennsylvania wineries, their livelihood hangs in the balance of the liquor privatization debate.
“It’s definitely a complex issue,” said Mario Mazza, vice president and general manager of Mazza Vineyards, one of the state’s largest producers of wine, located on Lake Erie in the town of North East. “We definitely feel there are things to be gained in improving the system.”
Under the current system, wineries are beholden to the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board to approve and place their products. Wineries are charged a nonrefundable $150 fee per label to approve their wine to be sold in stores. If the LCB doesn’t like the product and declines to carry it, the winery has nowhere else to turn.
With a privatized model, a winery could go down the street to the next distributor to sell its product.
“The benefit of privatization for Pennsylvania wineries is the possibility of more local retail outlets for the consumer to purchase Pennsylvania wines, while other existing state efforts to promote Pennsylvania wineries will and can continue,” said state Rep. Chris Ross, R-Chester, chair of the Liquor Control Committee.
Although he believes improving the system could provide better service to consumers, Mr. Mazza said many of the proposals for privatization fall short.
Read More
If the legislation is not written carefully, a private model could allow big-box stores to gobble up licenses, he said.
“When you talk about privatization, if they were just to sell the licenses and they get bought up by [grocery chain] Wegman’s, you’re not going to have someone to go down the street to necessarily,” he said.
“If they get the licenses, it’s not going to be good for the local producers who support the local economy nor will it be good for consumer selection,” Mr. Mazza said. “We’re totally in favor of improving customer service accessibility. Absolutely we want to see those things, and as a wine consumer, I would love to see those things improve and continue to improve –– it just has to be done very carefully.”
For some smaller wineries, having the support of the PLCB can be advantageous, Mr. Mazza said.
In 2012, the PLCB launched the Pennsylvania Preferred Wine Program in an effort to expand the selection of Pennsylvania products in state stores. Through the program, wineries have the opportunity to place up to 10 products in a select number of state stores of their choosing.
“One of the things we have noticed in the wine program is that those wineries that put wine in stores around the geographical region where the winery is saw better sales simply because of name recognition,” said Stacy Kriedeman, director of the Office of External Affairs at the PLCB.
Currently, the program has 59 wines and 19 wineries, with more wineries signing up to participate, she said.
Mr. Mazza, who chairs the Pennsylvania Wine Marketing and Research Program of the Department of Agriculture that works in conjunction with the PLCB and Pennsylvania Winery Association, said he applauds what the PLCB has done with the program and hopes it expands.
“We have support in the system, and there are Pennsylvania wineries who are able to promote their products through that system,” said Mr. Mazza. “We’ve done business in other states, and it’s not that easy.”
Pennsylvania ranks fifth nationally in the amount of grapes grown, at nearly 14,000 acres, and seventh in production of wine, according to the winery association, which said the state’s grape and wine industry has a $2 billion annual economic impact.
Over the past 30 years, the number of wineries has increased from 27 to 123 and they produce more than 970,000 gallons, according to the association.
Not every winery feels it has a stake in the privatization debate.
Becky and her husband, Sam Best, bought Lakeview Wine Cellars in North East as a part of their retirement plan, but have no plans to place their product in PLCB outlets or, if it happens, private stores.
“When we first opened up, we were looking at doing the PLCB but they would only give you 50 percent of retail value,” Mr. Best said. “I couldn’t afford to give my wine away for 50 percent off.”
Because the small winery produces only about 4,000 gallons a year, the Bests chose to sell only from their winery instead. They also noted that the PLCB charges for storage if a product doesn’t move.
“We have a lot of Pittsburgh people come up this way who would like to see us elsewhere, but it’s not in our business model,” Ms. Best said.
“While it would be nice to be recognized by the PLCB, we, as such a small business, cannot take that kind of hit from them,” said Ms. Best, who added that their small operation means they would have to ramp up their production quite a bit.
“This was our retirement dream –– my husband and I don’t want it to be a nightmare. We enjoy interacting with our customers,” she said.
“We decided early on we wanted to meet our customers face to face, which works good for us as a small winery,” added Mr. Best. “We are able to provide a more intimate experience in a country setting than just a commercial experience or than the liquor store walking up and down the aisle.”
Mr. Best isn’t entirely sure if privatization will necessarily help small wineries either.
“For us to work with a retailer, they would take almost the same amount that the state store takes, from what I understand. For us to distribute wines in New York state, we have to pay distributor 30 percent,” he said.
He explained that if they were to sell in a place like Premier Wine & Spirits stores in Buffalo, both the distributor who sells the wine in New York state and the liquor store would take a percentage, probably comparable to the PLCB’s cut.
In addition to selling from the winery, Pennsylvania producers can operate up to five retail outlets, sell at festivals or make direct sales to restaurants. All other sales must be conducted through state-owned shops.
House Bill 466, the liquor privatization bill that passed the General Assembly, was vetoed by Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf last month. As the budget impasse continues, the debate over liquor privatization remains a priority for Republican leaders, while Democrats generally oppose privatization, saying the state could modernize the system while retaining control of it.
Madison Russ is an intern with the Pennsylvania Legislative Correspondents Association.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.