The indictment of Attorney General Kathleen Kane roiled the existing speculation on who might replace her, and when and how she might be forced to step down.
Ms. Kane, who was formally arraigned in Montgomery County on Saturday, continues to insist that such speculation is misplaced. After a grand jury handed up the charges of perjury and leaking grand jury material against her, she insisted that she had no plans to resign. Her spokesman, Chuck Ardo, said Friday that she plans to be the state’s top prosecutor for years to come.
“She believes she will be able to prove her innocence and run for re-election,” he said.
But politicians in both parties had already been making plans to run for her seat next year. And, amid a bipartisan chorus of calls for her resignation, Harrisburg officials were discussing the mechanisms on how she might be forced out while anticipating the process of putting a successor in place.
State Sen. John Rafferty, R-Montgomery, announced a bid for the office in June. He is the only declared candidate for the 2016 election, but several other officials are assessing the race. Rob Gleason, the state GOP chairman, said another Montgomery County Republican, state Rep. Todd Stephens, was considering the race. Mr. Stephens confirmed his interest in an interview earlier this summer with the website PoliticsPa.
Across the aisle, but in the same county, Commissioner Josh Shapiro is reportedly also considering the contest. Mr. Shapiro, who was courted by national Democrats earlier this year as a potential U.S. Senate candidate, declined to comment on the attorney general’s race. But a source close to the commissioner confirmed that he was exploring the race and said he was likely to make a decision sometime this fall.
Read More
John Morganelli, the district attorney of Northampton County, is another possible Democratic contender. Mr. Morganelli, who could not be reached for comment, ran for the office before, winning the Democratic nomination in 2008, but losing the general election to Tom Corbett, who was then the incumbent. Mr. Morganelli also considered a bid for the Democratic nomination for lieutenant governor in 2014. Earlier this year, he spoke out critically against Gov. Tom Wolf over the Democrat’s decision to impose a moratorium on the death penalty in the state.
The district attorneys in the state’s two largest cities are also Democrats. Through spokesmen, both Philadelphia’s Seth Williams and Allegheny County’s Stephen A. Zappala Jr. declined to comment on the race, although neither has made any overt moves toward organizing a campaign.
“Being district attorney of Allegheny County is an honor and beyond that I would not comment,” Mr. Zappala said of the possibility, according to his spokesman, Mike Manko.
Long before the election, however, Ms. Kane could conceivably leave office under a variety of scenarios. State Rep. Daryl Metcalfe, R-Butler, has been a long-standing proponent of Ms. Kane’s impeachment, citing legal and policy disagreements that range well beyond the new criminal charges. Impeachment would require a majority of the GOP-controlled House. If the impeachment vote succeeded, that would set the stage for a trial in the Senate that would require a two-thirds majority for conviction.
The Associated Press reported that Ron Castille, a former chief justice of the state Supreme Court, has suggested that Ms. Kane could be ousted through the court’s disciplinary authority over lawyers. Pennsylvania’s Constitution specifies that “[n]o person shall be eligible to the office of Attorney General except a member of the bar of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania.”
If she were to lose her law license through a disciplinary procedure separate from the criminal charges against her, she would be ineligible to continue in office.
However it occurred, a vacancy would give Mr. Wolf the power to nominate someone to serve the balance of her term, which expires at the end of 2016. The nominee would have to be confirmed by a two-thirds majority of the Senate.
That’s the procedure that was used earlier this year after former Treasurer Rob McCord resigned in connection with his guilty plea on charges of extorting campaign contributions. The Senate confirmed Mr. Wolf’s choice of Timothy A. Reese to serve the balance of the McCord term. Some members of the Senate’s Republican leadership were disgruntled by that process, however, contending that Mr. Wolf blindsided them in announcing his nominee without sufficient consultation.
Drew Crompton, chief of staff to Senate leader Joe Scarnati, signaled the leadership’s continuing concern with a Twitter message Thursday: “If there is a vacancy for Atty General, the Senate Rs will not confirm the nominee unless we have been included in the selection process.”
Elaborating in a subsequent interview, he said, “We were really put off by the way the selection process was done on treasurer ... [there was] absolutely no consultation.
“We worked through that process and ultimately confirmed him — I’m not saying that [Mr. Reese] isn’t a good guy, but we made it clear to the governor’s office that that isn’t the way the process should be.
“If they give us a name, ‘take it or leave it,’ we might just leave it,” he said.
Typically, in analogous cases in recent years, where a vacancy occurs in a state office with an election looming, the governor nominates a candidate who pledges not to run for the office for the subsequent term, so as not to confer the advantages of incumbency on a candidate.
Asked to comment on Mr. Crompton’s complaint, Jeffrey Sheridan, Mr. Wolf’s press secretary, said, “The Constitution of Pennsylvania makes clear the governor’s role in nominations, as it does the Senate’s role. With regards to this particular situation, we cannot comment on matters that have not happened.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.