Second of two parts. Sunday: Tom Corbett, even before winning his party’s 2010 nomination, began wooing the gas industry. Today: Post-nomination, the money rolled in, buying a seat at the administration’s table.
The briefing memo from a Pittsburgh-based fundraiser recounted the star-studded first encounter between Pennsylvania’s gubernatorial front-runner and a leader of its growing gas extraction industry.
“Please note that you met [Range Resources CEO] John Pinkerton at a Corbett for Governor fundraiser in West Mifflin, Pennsylvania with Jeb Bush,” according to the memo, prepared for an Aug. 30, 2010, luncheon hosted by Mr. Pinkerton for Mr. Corbett. “John Pinkerton flew in for the event and gave [Florida] Governor Bush a ride back to Dallas.”
The briefing memo — one of hundreds of Corbett campaign documents recently obtained by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette — went on: “Expected attendance is 20 people. This event will raise in excess of 50k.”
That would represent a sliver of the money Mr. Corbett raised from gas interests during his 2010 general election win, which gave him the governorship and cemented his party’s role as friend of the now-mature industry. While Mr. Corbett is now a private citizen, his party’s partnership with the industry continues to reap dividends for both sides. The gas companies operate without a severance tax, and their political giving in Pennsylvania favors Republicans four times as much as Democrats.
Mr. Corbett was out of state last week, and through a spokesman he declined a phone interview.
Read More
“During my administration, I met with thousands of people who were interested in helping to build a stronger Pennsylvania,” Mr. Corbett wrote, in lieu of an interview. “I worked with the private sector to create jobs and provide cheaper energy sources for all Pennsylvanians. We succeeded in creating a more business-friendly environment that allowed the private sector to create over 150,000 jobs and dramatically reduced the state’s unemployment rate. The energy industry was a driving force behind those efforts and I was proud of the work we accomplished for the people of Pennsylvania.”
Environmental advocates saw the results differently.
“This was the driller’s playground during the Corbett administration,” said Jan Jarrett, who is coordinating a four-state research project on shale gas drilling for the left-leaning Pennsylvania Budget and Policy Center.
The big money in Texas
A week after winning the Republican gubernatorial nomination in 2010, Tom Corbett headed for Texas, with a meeting schedule including legendary oilman T. Boone Pickens and executives of Cabot Oil & Gas and Alta Resources. The nominee was armed with briefing memos, prepared by fundraisers, describing each business’s operations, nationally and in Pennsylvania, plus any recent history of donations to the Republican Governors Association.
The trip wasn’t primarily dedicated to fundraising, said C. Alan Walker, who was the Corbett campaign’s finance chair and became the administration’s secretary of the Department of Community and Economic Development.
“I was not in any meetings at which there were any requests for money,” said Mr. Walker, who accompanied Mr. Corbett to Texas. “I think the governor really just wanted to find out how big the gas play was in Pennsylvania and how the big money in Texas perceived it.”
Asked how the nominee kept campaign finance considerations separate from his efforts to learn about the gas industry, Mr. Walker said he never heard any talk of concerns. “You must not know Tom Corbett very well,” he said. “I know the governor well enough to know that he wouldn’t want to be beholden to any industry.”
On tour
Gas executives were on the guest list for Mr. Corbett’s visit to Washington, D.C., in June 2010. “Many of the individuals you met in Texas suggested a fundraiser led and hosted by ANGA,” the America’s Natural Gas Alliance, a fundraiser wrote.
In late August, according to the internal documents, Mr. Corbett was back in Texas, attending the lunch hosted by Mr. Pinkerton and a reception with the CEO of NiSource Gas Transmission & Storage. Each event was expected to raise at least $50,000.
Mark Hanna, a gas industry consultant who helped to organize the NiSource event, said last week that Mr. Corbett carefully kept policy discussions separate from fundraising requests.
“That was the thing about Corbett. He operated, as an attorney general, very straight down the line,” Mr. Hanna said. “He didn’t really mix things that he shouldn’t mix.”
By October, the campaign had a spreadsheet called “Marcellus Shale email” including contact information for 55 gas company execs.
The effort was successful. According to Marcellus Money, a project of Common Cause Pennsylvania and the Conservation Voters of Pennsylvania, gas interests gave $984,000 to Mr. Corbett’s 2010 campaign, versus $174,000 to his Democratic opponent, Dan Onorato.
Seats at the table
After Mr. Corbett beat Mr. Onorato, the spreadsheet became a tool in the push to raise nearly $4 million for his inauguration. The fundraisers created new spreadsheets showing how much each of around 100 large companies — including around 20 gas firms — had contributed to the campaign and had pledged to the inauguration.
Of the 24 “diamond” inaugural backers who pledged $50,000 or more, eight were gas industry firms. Two other gas extraction companies became “platinum” sponsors, at $25,000.
On the night before the inauguration, diamond and platinum sponsors were rewarded with an “inaugural benefactors dinner” at The Hotel Hershey. Tom and Susan Corbett would thank them, allow “candid photos,” introduce his planned cabinet and lead a champagne toast, according to the program.
Each table was assigned a host. According to the seating chart, Table 8 was for executives from gas firms Alpha Natural Resources, Atlas Energy, Cabot Oil & Gas, Chesapeake Energy, Consol Energy, NiSource, Range Resources, Talisman Energy USA, plus one utility, FirstEnergy. Its host was Michael Krancer, who soon became Mr. Corbett’s secretary of the Department of Environmental Protection.

Mr. Krancer, now a partner specializing in energy development at the Philadelphia law firm Blank Rome, could not be reached for comment.
Mr. Krancer “knew what his marching orders were,” said Ms. Jarrett. “Enforcement went down. Fines went down,” until late in the administration, when DEP issued some big fines for gas industry environmental violations, she said. “They turned over the keys to the state to the gas drillers, really.”
Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542. Twitter @richelord





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.