WASHINGTON – Lawmakers are debating sweeping federal education changes that would dismantle the unpopular 2001 No Child Left Behind Law, but Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., has a narrower focus for now.

His mission, he said Tuesday, is to persuade his colleagues to include a measure to require more extensive background checks for teachers and to penalize administrators who knowingly recommend suspected child predators to other districts.

His proposal has been introduced as an amendment and could get a vote this week.

The underlying bill’s sponsors — Sens. Lamar Alexander, R-Tenn., and Patty Murray, D-Wash. — have been working with other senators to incorporate other proposals into their bill, but it’s unlikely Mr. Toomey’s legislation will get similar treatment.

Advertise with us

Mr. Alexander has been one of the measure’s most vocal opponents, saying background checks are an issue for states and local school boards, not the federal government.

But Mr. Toomey said a patchwork of laws won’t prevent a principal in one state from recommending a known predator to a school in another state, a practice he calls “passing the trash.”

“Since when can the laws of one state reach into and be enforced in another state? It can’t. Doesn’t work. The only way to deal with this cross-border abuse, this horrendous abuse of kids, is with federal legislation,” Mr. Toomey said during a Senate floor speech Tuesday evening.

Co-sponsored by Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., the amendment would require schools to conduct background checks of all school employees, coaches, volunteers, bus drivers and others with unsupervised access to children.

It would prohibit school districts from hiring anyone ever convicted of violent or sexual crimes, homicide or crimes against children such as abuse, neglect or pornography. It also would prohibit hiring people convicted within five years of felony assault or drug offenses.

Advertise with us

The amendment faces opposition from the National Education Association, which says the Toomey bill is too rigid, that it violates privacy and that it encourages the blacklisting of employees merely suspected or accused of misconduct.

The association supports the concept of background checks but prefers legislation that would accommodate differences in state criminal laws, lets school districts evaluate individual applicants to determine whether a particular crime is job-related, and prohibits school districts from withholding information about allegations of child abuse in a school setting.

Opposition won’t keep Mr. Toomey from reintroducing his amendment, which passed the House last session but failed to make it to the Senate floor.

The debate over the Every Child Achieves Act is “the perfect opportunity” to try again, Mr. Toomey said Tuesday. “I’m pushing hard.”

Mr. Toomey and Mr. Manchin have introduced the measure twice before as a stand-alone bill and once as an amendment to another bill. Each time their efforts were rebuffed.

Advertise with us

Rep. Mike Fitzpatrick, R-Bucks, sponsored companion legislation, which easily passed the House in two different sessions. He is expected to introduce it a third time this week as the House considers its version of the education reauthorization.

Mr. Toomey thinks his chances in the Senate might be better now.

“I’m not sure we’re going to get there but the folks who oppose us they have figured out that I’m not going away, and they realize that however things turn out in the next few days I’m going to stay at this,” he said.