HARRISBURG — One day after GOP leaders unveiled a budget, the state House voted mostly along party lines to pass the plan, which Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf is likely to veto.
The Senate is expected to vote on the budget in the coming days and send it to the governor before the state's fiscal year ends Tuesday.
House Republicans on Saturday also unveiled new provisions for a pensions bill, which they said had been agreed upon with Senate Republicans, and voted it out of committee. Unlike an earlier version of the bill, the amended plan would not require current state and public school workers to pay more to maintain their current retirement benefit. But it would send most future state and public school hires — though not police or corrections officers — into defined-contribution retirement plans rather than the current defined-benefit pension systems.
The $30.1 billion Republican plan, which would not raise taxes, relies in part upon revenue from moving the government business in wine and liquor sales to the private sector.
Mr. Wolf has called for major changes in state tax policy and intended to provide money to reduce local property taxes and increase funding for education. He proposed raising the rates of the sales and personal income taxes, with some of the money going to lower property taxes, and enacting a severance tax on natural gas drilling to provide money to schools. None of those proposals are reflected in the plan the House voted on Saturday.
The governor said Friday that he would veto the budget if it were to reach him in its current form. On Saturday, Mr. Wolf’s budget secretary, Randy Albright, would not say if he anticipates the governor would veto the entire budget or only parts of it.
Read More
“That’s a decision he’ll make when there’s actually a budget on his desk,” Mr. Albright said.
Republican House Majority Leader Dave Reed, R-Indiana, said he hoped it would be the latter.
Budget timeline
June 27: GOP pension bill advances after Democrats walk out of committee meeting
June 26: The Republicans start to advance their own budget; Wolf threatens veto
June 25: The governor says he hasn't seen a GOP proposed budget, so can't say whether he'd veto
June 24: Lawmakers begin to discuss possibility of submitting budget with none of the governor's input
June 23: Stalemate -- Meetings between governor and Republicans mostly focus on scheduling future meetings
“As we look forward to continued negotiations with the governor, we would certainly hope that the governor would consider at least signing this budget to keep government operating, even if he feels the need to line-item veto one or two of the items that he wants to continue to have a discussion about over the summer,” Mr. Reed said. “There’s no need for government to be interrupted from an operational perspective during that time.”
During the House floor debate on Saturday, Democratic House Appropriations chairman Joe Markosek, D-Monroeville, criticized the spending plan as having only Republican input.
"It does not reflect any sort of compromise, which is what we do here at budget time. It reflects a unilateral, take-it-or-leave-it approach," Mr. Markosek said.
Rep. Dan Frankel, D-Squirrel Hill, said the budget lacked a shale gas tax, and was balanced in irresponsible ways.
Democrats have criticized the budget as failing to make millions in required Social Security payments to school districts, not making appropriate child welfare payments to counties and failing to account for millions in mandated Medicaid spending.
Acknowledging the high profile of education funding as a political issue, Republicans emphasized the increases their budget would provide: $100 million in the main K-12 budget line, $25 million for Pre-K Counts, $20 million for special education. (Mr. Wolf had proposed increases of $400 million for the main K-12 line, $100 million for Pre-K Counts and $100 million for special education).
Democrats argued that even the new money Republicans proposed for schools would be overshadowed by a decrease in school worker pension payments (a change Republicans attributed to their use of more recent employee and salary information, but which they said would meet the state's required contribution) and a proposed adjustment in how the state pays its Social Security contributions.
In their criticism of the GOP budget, Democrats repeatedly invoked the name of former Gov. Tom Corbett, who lost his re-election bid to Mr. Wolf by nearly 10 points.
“This is Tom Corbett all over again,” Sen. Vincent Hughes, D-Philadelphia, told reporters.
Republicans countered their proposal did not include any taxes, and said Mr. Wolf’s plan did not have the support to pass their chamber.
"The governor's proposal just didn't pass the smell test," said Rep. Rick Saccone, R-Elizabeth Township.
"You can't spend what you don't have," said Rep. Kate Harper, R-Montgomery.
She noted that several weeks ago, the entire House voted unanimously against the tax increases in Mr. Wolf's plan, citing services that aren’t currently taxed but would be under Mr. Wolf’s proposal.
"We would be taxing things we've never taxed before, toddlers in daycare, kids in college for room and board...That's what that budget required.". .. . . . I couldn't bring myself to do that and none of us could," she added.
Earlier Saturday, Republicans in the House State Government Committee approved legislation to enroll most future Pennsylvania state and public school employees in defined-contribution retirement plans, but not until Democratic members left the meeting after protesting the procedures Republicans used.
Unlike the pensions plan that passed the Senate in May, the amended measure would not require most current state and public school workers to pay more to maintain their current level of retirement benefit, though current workers would be affected by an “anti-spiking” measure and a change to how lump-sum withdrawals would be calculated.
When the committee took up the measure, Democrats protested that they had received the 11-page amendment only upon their arrival at the meeting.
“Most of us can count on this committee that you do not need our votes to move this forward,” said Rep. Mary Jo Daley, D-Montgomery. “But on something that is so incredibly important for state employees, public school employees, public school districts, it just seems not really a great way to do business.”
Afterward, Mr. Metcalfe said he believed the Democrats had been given a fair chance to assess the legislation.
Republicans also plan to move ahead with their plan to shift the state’s alcohol business to the private sector. Mr. Reed said Saturday that House and Senate Republicans had agreed on a plan to lease the state’s wholesale business in wine and liquor and gradually sell off its retail stores.
Republicans control both legislative chambers by wide majorities: 30-19 in the Senate and 118-80 in the House.
Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com or 717-787-4254 or on Twitter @KateGiammarise. Karen Langley: klangley@post-gazette.com or 717-787-2141 or on Twitter @karen_langley





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.