HARRISBURG — A federal judge has struck down a Pennsylvania law intended to protect crime victims from upsetting conduct by those who hurt them.
The “Revicitimization Relief Act” gave prosecutors and victims of violent crimes, or their kin, the right to sue to stop “conduct which perpetuates the continuing effect of the crime on the victim,” which the law defined to include actions causing mental anguish.
A Republican state representative, Mike Vereb of Montgomery County, called for the measure after a small college in Vermont announced that Mumia Abu-Jamal, who is serving a life sentence for the 1981 killing of a Philadelphia police officer, would address graduates through an audio recording.
The bill passed the House of Representatives unanimously and the Senate 37-11 and was signed into law by former Gov. Tom Corbett in October.
In a decision Tuesday, Chief Judge Christopher C. Conner of the Middle District of Pennsylvania found the law is “manifestly unconstitutional,” saying “the enactment is unlawfully purposed, vaguely executed and patently overbroad in scope.”
“A past criminal offense does not extinguish the offender’s constitutional right to free expression,” Judge Conner wrote. “The First Amendment does not evanesce at the prison gate, and its enduring guarantee of freedom of speech subsumes the right to expressive conduct that some may find offensive.”
Read More
Steve Miskin, a spokesman for House Republicans, disagreed with the ruling, saying the law only allows a case to be brought in court.
“The Revictimization Relief Act merely creates a cause of action for relief,” he said. “Any relief under the act is only available through the courts, who are the true guardians of constitutional rights.”
Mr. Vereb said Wednesday that he has asked Attorney General Kathleen Kane to appeal the decision. A spokesman for the attorney general said the office is reviewing the ruling.
The law was challenged by Abu-Jamal and other inmates, as well as by journalists and others who use the speech of inmates in their work.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.