HARRISBURG — Legislative Republicans aren’t just objecting to the tax increases in Gov. Tom Wolf’s first budget proposal.

They’re taking issue with the bottom line itself.

Mr. Wolf, a Democrat, has presented his budget as one with a general fund, the state’s main operating account, of $29.88 billion, a little less than $1 billion more than in the current fiscal year.

Republicans, pointing to the budget’s financial statement, disagree.

Advertise with us

“You don’t raise $4.5 billion in taxes to increase spending by $800 million,” Senate Majority Leader Jake Corman, R-Centre, said after the governor gave his address Tuesday. “Come on. Let’s all deal in reality here.”

Mr. Corman, a former Appropriations Committee chairman, said the governor’s budget would have totaled $33 billion had he not transferred out of the main fund $1.7 billion in pension payments and $2.1 billion that he proposes to use for property tax relief.

How to account for the governor’s property tax proposal, which he says would reduce homeowner property taxes by an average of more than half, is key to the dispute. The administration argued Wednesday that a fair tally of the governor’s proposed tax increases does not include the portion of money the state would send to school districts to reduce local property taxes.

In a memo entitled “Getting the Numbers Right,” budget secretary Randy Albright wrote that it is wrong to say the proposal includes a $4.7 billion revenue increase.

An accurate assessment, he wrote, “must be based on the net revenue change — i.e., the difference between revenue increases, on the one hand, and revenue dedicated to tax reduction, on the other.”

Advertise with us

In a briefing a day earlier, Mr. Albright had said: “We think that the tax package totals out in the [2015-16] fiscal year with a net of about $4.6 billion, I think. And then once you reduce the tax relief that’s accounted for in that number, it’s an increase of about $2.5 billion.”

The new revenue would come in large part from raising the personal income tax rate from 3.07 percent to 3.7 percent and the state sales tax rate from 6 percent to 6.6 percent while expanding the products and services subject to the tax. Revenue also would be raised by imposing an extraction tax on natural gas and adding to the tax on cigarettes, while dollars are projected to be lost through the governor’s plan to cut the rate of the corporate net income tax.

Steve Miskin, a spokesman for House Republicans, said that money raised from state taxpayers is still revenue, no matter how it is spent.

“It’s not like it’s just free money,” he said. “It defies logic to say it doesn’t count.”