It’s come to this: State Attorney General Kathleen Kane might be criminally charged for leaking grand jury information to a newspaper. Or so we’re told … thanks to an apparent grand-jury leak to a newspaper.

“Look at the irony,” said Jim Burn, chair of the state Democratic Party. “This is a leaked grand-jury report, and no one has seen it yet. We shouldn’t rush to judgment.”

Other public officials were less vocal Thursday, when the Philadelphia Inquirer reported a statewide grand jury is recommending Ms. Kane be charged with perjury and contempt of court. The paper cited “numerous people familiar with the decision.” Harrisburg politicians, including Gov. Tom Corbett and Gov.-elect Tom Wolf, either declined comment or did not respond to requests.

The investigation of Ms. Kane stems from an earlier grand jury, this one investigating Philadelphia civil-rights activist J. Whyatt Mondesire. Mr. Mondesire has denied wrongdoing and was never charged, but the inquiry was disclosed in a Philadelphia Daily News story. Suspicion for the leak fell on Ms. Kane, who’s feuded with Frank G. Fina, a former prosecutor who handled the Mondesire case.

Advertise with us

“It’s a sad day for Pennsylvania,” said Heather Heidelbaugh, a Republican Allegheny County Councilor who is contemplating a run for Ms. Kane’s post in 2016. “It’s a stain on the office, and on her. ... I assume [this week’s] leak is true. There’s always a conundrum there.”

This is far from the first disclosure involving the inquiry into Ms. Kane. Among other dispatches, she was involved in a widely reported car accident on her way to testify before the grand jury. And Duquesne University law professor Bruce Ledewitz drew a distinction between the leaks Ms. Kane is accused of, and leaks about the accusation itself.

“Assuming it’s accurate, [Thursday’s leak] just speeds up the clock on something which had to come out eventually,” he said. By contrast, the Mondesire leak “is said to be about a vendetta.”

Mr. Ledewitz said the contempt charge is “what you’d expect from a leak of grand-jury material. But the other charges would be quite significant. Perjury — she wouldn’t even be eligible to serve as attorney general.”

If Ms. Kane is charged, that too will distinguish her from Mr. Mondesire. When a grand jury doesn’t recommend charges, “the public is never supposed to hear about the investigation,” said Bruce Antkowiak, a former federal prosecutor who teaches law at St. Vincent College. That’s to protect an innocent person’s reputation.

Advertise with us

Federal investigations would be suspended “if there was any hint of a leak,” he said. “It would undermine the integrity of the whole process.”

So should a grand jury start investigating the grand jury that investigated the grand-jury leak?

“I don’t know,” Mr. Antkowiak said. “They took away my power to convene grand juries a long time ago.”

Harrisburg correspondent Kate Giammarise contributed. Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.