As the investigation of the Pennsylvania Turnpike reached the end of the road this week, observers were wondering whether the trip was worth it.
How did an 85-page grand jury presentment, unveiled with great fanfare in March 2013, end with none of the eight defendants receiving prison time?
Did Attorney General Kathleen Kane’s office mishandle the case, or were its allegations that Turnpike officials and a state senator rigged bids in a “pay-to-play” scheme overblown from the outset?
Was justice done?
“I don’t want to comment on that,” said Laurel Brandstetter, the case’s primary prosecutor who said a larger team of defense attorneys has her sometimes feeling “outmanned” but not outgunned.
One former federal prosecutor called the punishment “light” for a corruption case. An attorney for one defendant said his client had been “selectively prosecuted” for conduct that is a way of life in political circles.
This week, former Turnpike CEO Joseph Brimmeier pleaded guilty to conflict-of-interest charges with the turnpike’s former chief operating officer, George Hatalowich. The men agreed to five years probation, community service, and $2,500 fines. A former Turnpike Commission chairman, Mitchell Rubin, received two years probation, a fine and community service in an earlier plea deal.
Other defendants were more fortunate. A Dauphin County judge dismissed all but one charge facing former Lackawanna County state Sen. Robert Mellow; Ms. Kane’s office dropped the remaining charge. Two businessmen entered a rehabilitation program; they admitted no guilt and will have their records expunged if they complete probation and community service.
J.J. Abbott, a spokesman for Ms. Kane, said the case had “a reasonable resolution. The two main actors are now convicted felons and will have to carry that badge, and it sends a signal that this behavior isn’t acceptable and there are consequences for it.”
The case’s outcome is “worse than a slap on the hand. It’s a pat on the back, and the big loser here is the attorney general,” said Eric Epstein, coordinator of Rock the Capital, a Harrisburg watchdog group.
The pleas came during a difficult week for Ms. Kane. On Monday she appeared before a grand jury investigating leaks from her office. On Wednesday her office had to walk back from statements she made on CNN the day before when she suggested that salacious emails that state employees sent included pornographic images of children.
Her office faced hurdles in the Turnpike case, including Ms. Brandstetter’s departure in August, not long before a November trial was set. Ms. Brandstetter denies her departure was related to the Turnpike case, saying she “was offered some opportunities that came up unexpectedly” at the firm of Leech Tishman.
She said that, in a case with a legal team representing six defendants, she was often the only commonwealth attorney.
Ms. Brandstetter’s previous cases included the successful 2012 prosecution of former Beaver County state Rep. Mike Veon. While she said she was “able to adequately represent the commonwealth [in the Turnpike case] … I consistently asked for help throughout the investigation and prosecution.”
Bruce Beemer, the first deputy attorney general, said the attorney general’s office provided additional attorneys during “critical periods” and that Ms. Brandstetter would have had two lawyers at her side during the trial.
Bruce Antkowiak, a former federal prosecutor who is now a law professor at St. Vincent College, said that “compared to other public corruption cases, the punishment is certainly light,” but pay-to-play cases are difficult to prosecute.
The public might connect the dots between making a big-dollar contribution and earning a lucrative contract, but in a courtroom, Mr. Antkowiak said such connections can’t be implicit.
“It appeared to me that they were trying to criminalize political activity,” said attorney Mark B. Sheppard.
Mr. Sheppard’s client, Dennis Miller, was accused of garnering computer-systems work for his employer by trading on campaign contributions and friendships with Turnpike staffers, but “there were other vendors who gave far greater sums, and who lavished far greater gratuities at persons at the Turnpike,” said Mr. Sheppard.
He said Mr. Miller, who was one of the defendants who entered rehabilitation without pleading guilty, never engaged in quid pro quo.
The Turnpike investigation began while Gov. Tom Corbett was attorney general. William Keisling, whose 1993 book “When the Levee Breaks” explores Turnpike patronage, called the case “a travesty,” one originally intended to embarrass Democrats for a bipartisan problem.
“It’s all done with a wink and a nod,” Mr. Keisling said. Singling out individual defendants for committing politics as usual “reminds me of a show trial they would have in the Soviet bloc: You march out your enemies to remove them from the picture, and leave the system intact.”
“It’s not much of a prosecution and not much of a result,” said Bruce Ledewitz, a law professor at Duquesne University, but “the public will believe a crime took place and it wasn’t punished. That’s the worst of both worlds.”
Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.